Hadrian House – the buildings formerly occupied by the ‘Hustler’ snooker and pool club – is to become more city centre student accommodation. I only discovered this recently, but this is no surprise given the startling lack of coverage in the city. The Chronicle – beacon of democracy in the North East – confirmed it in February in an article containing spectacularly little detail. It merely reported the facts, as the education system teaches us to do so well. The newspaper earlier reported (in January) that the club was to ‘make way for a major student accommodation block in the heart of Newcastle.’ This is as well as another block of student accommodation in Castle Leazes.
Little support for more student accommodation
It is clear that there is no popular support for more student accommodation in the city. In fact this is one of those issues on which most people agree. Surely popular support is a prerequisite in a democracy. But there isn’t even the illusion of democracy in public decision-making in Newcastle, and this should at the very least concern us, perhaps even anger us. Because if there were, the city would be a very different place.
The democratic institutions are so opaque as to be meaningless. How are such motions as the development of more student accommodation decided and approved? How do they determine whether it is a policy with popular support? The fact is that the average citizen has no influence over the decisions of its council. The council, then, is merely a collector of taxes on behalf of those who control it.
Who does more student accommodation benefit? Well, what does it provide? Students are but one strata of society, yet it seems that the city centre is being designed exclusively for them.
The endless growth of hideous student blocks, weeds that drain the life of all that surrounds them, is an insight into whose interests local institutions serve.
Many students, especially the increasing number of international students, are temporary. They are not concerned with the future of the city beyond their degree. Thus their short-term stay is ideal for the short-term speculations of modern capitalism. They are also guaranteed: there will always be someone to fill a student room, and for a set length of time.
They are wealthy, or if not, then provided with loans and grants to simulate wealth. Thus they can spend money in the trendy bars and restaurants and local supermarkets that spring up wherever they are found.
They are one of the few remaining groups in society who will live in poor conditions without raising a fuss, unlike, say, poor people. Such people require space and a decent standard of living; they are conscious of their rights. Not ideal for maximising profit margins, nor for those who have to pretend to care about their concerns every so often. And if any students do raise a fuss, they will be gone in a couple of years.
Profit at all costs
Evidently, then, the only reason is profit. Profit at all costs. Never mind the will of the people or anything maudlin and romantic like that. Because if the local economy is thriving, then everyone
must be happy. And twenty-thousand students spending someone else’s money is a great way to get the economy growing. Never mind the poor in the council estates; never mind the homeless; never mind the working mothers; never mind the cultural decay. Never mind, never mind, never mind.
Portable propaganda machines and the near-universal addiction to social media means that most people, especially those under a certain age, find it difficult not to define themselves in the way that advertisers do. People are ‘18-25’ or they are ‘introverts’ or they are ‘creatives’. Et cetera ad nauseum. Individuality itself is a style to be packaged and marketed to the ignorant by the ignorant. Thus the idea that students do not require segregation from the rest of society on the basis of their marketable status as students is becoming increasingly hard for people to imagine. But ask: why is it almost axiomatic that students live separate from us?
If we reject this notion, then one solution to the shortage of housing in the city might be to have students, the creatives, the crazies, the introverts, the foodies, the vegans, the whole range of banality, living together in what used to be called ‘communities’. There might even be space for the poor and the jobless. We might even use the word ‘class’.
Hadrian House, democracy, and control
Hadrian House is no doubt ‘dilapidated’. Most would agree that the building is wasted and in need of work. Yet clearly there is potential, and I have often thought it would make a great European-style arcade filled with various businesses, galleries, community projects, etc. (Maybe even a snooker and pool hall.) Perhaps it is beyond salvation. The point is that the people of the city should work together to decide what becomes of it, if it must be sold.
Students, as anyone who knows anything will know, have been a reliable source of revolutionary activity since 1848. But the education system, coupled with the privatisation of the internet, has seemingly mastered the mass production of passive machines, who see learning only as a means of getting a decent job, such that they might have money to spend once they graduate from their role as student into one of the many exciting options provided by the market economy. The continued destruction of this revolutionary seedbed is having a significant effect on wider society.
It is essential, then, that we recognise that we have control over our democratic institutions. That apathy and despair serve no function; that people have suffered and overcome vastly greater challenges in human history. In fact such apathy is ideal both for those shapers of policy who demand as little popular reaction as possible, and those marketing companies looking for new sections of the society to whom they can sell their products. The democratic institutions are encrusted and opaque, but they still exist in some form and can be exploited.
A final point: the owners of ‘Hustler’ did not want to leave the building. It seems that they were forced out of the building by the landlord, who had decided to sell. Never mind democracy! This is a successful business and one quite unique to Newcastle. It was one of the few places left where various groups in society would mix. In that sense it was something of a relic. Imagine,
the young talking to the middle-aged! But such is the nature of a political system designed to uphold and protect the ancient right of private property.
After the closure of J G Windows last year, it is evident that Newcastle is becoming another banal playground for the ignorant (educated, no doubt!) middle-classes and those with money. Like London but with one-hundred Greggs instead of thousand Prets. Unless, of course, we do something about it.






