Hartlepool’s flagship Middleton Grange shopping centre, bought on a long lease by the town’s mayoral development corporation (MDC) more than two years ago, remains at high financial risk in spite of being included in a town deal and after months of discussion of its problems.
External market pressures and cost factors could adversely affect its income, asset performance and long-term value, according to the latest report to the MDC’s audit and governance committee (AGC), which meets on 12 February.
The MDC was established in February 2023 and acquired a lease on the shopping centre in December that year, paid for out of a £10mn investment grant from Tees Valley Combined Authority (TVCA). Regeneration of the shopping centre was one of the projects included in Hartlepool’s £25mn town deal of 2021 and is now the responsibility of the MDC and Hartlepool Council jointly.
The Tees Valley Mayor, Lord Ben Houchen, was chair of both TVCA and Hartlepool MDC at the times of both the investment grant and the purchase.
In July 2024 the MDC board approved a strategic asset business plan which set out at a high level the actions required over a 12-18 month period to ensure that the underlying investment in the shopping centre was preserved while longer-term aspirations and viability were tested.
Vacancies and losses
On 6 November 2025 board members raised concerns at the number of vacancies in the shopping centre, and its value of zero, and suggested that discussions were required on how it could be brought back to life.
The chief executive said the MDC board would be meeting that December to discuss future options for the shopping centre, while cognisant of the fact that it would continue to generate losses because of retailers leaving.
Feasibility work would be carried out, the board was told, to look at whether partial demolitions were required to free up land for development, and further surveys would be carried out to identify how structurally safe the market hall was.
When the board met on 2 December it was told that assessment of the potential longer-term options for the future of the market hall were continuing in conjunction with the options for the regeneration of the wider Middleton Grange focus area.
Other risks
Middleton Grange is far from being the only high risk factor facing Hartlepool MDC. A separate report to the audit and governance committee lists insufficient [staff] capacity and capability across key technical roles; and unclear strategic direction. The latter is described in a particularly scathing summary:
“There is a risk that the organisation does not maintain a clear, coherent, and consistently communicated strategic direction, resulting in misaligned priorities, suboptimal use of resources, reduced stakeholder confidence, and diminished capacity to deliver strategic outcomes or adapt to change.”
There are additional intermediate level risks of an ineffective planning function leading to increased costs; the financial position and overall financial resilience of the MDC; asset management capability; insurability of assets; and inadequate governance due to an ineffective scheme of delegation.
Audit
As if all that was not enough, confusion over audit requirements when Hartlepool MDC was first set up are still having repercussions today.
The public inspection period for the 2022/23 audit is only now coming to an end; the 2023/24 audit is still not quite completed; and the statutory backdrop date of 3 February 2026 for completing the 2024/25 audit has almost certainly been missed.
The depressing details of this latest tale of financial woe in the Tees Valley empire of Mayor Houchen are spelled out in a report by Jo Moore, the Combined Authority’s (TVCA’s) interim director of finance and resources, in a report for the MDC’s audit and governance committee.
The story goes back to the establishment of the MDC in February 2023, when only six weeks remained until the end of the 2022/23 financial year. It was thought at the time that although separate accounts were required for that six-week period a full external audit was not needed.
Instead of a full audit under Public Sector Audit Appointments (PSAA) arrangements, officials concluded that an Annual Governance and Accountability Return (AGAR) under the Small Authorities Auditor Appointments (SAAA) process would do.
While that was confirmed, a decision to carry the six weeks of transactions forward into the following year (2023/24) led to unanticipated problems. When the provisional audit completion report for 2023/24 was presented in May 2025 it incorporated the six weeks of 2022/23 transactions. They then had to be removed and the 2023/24 audit updated accordingly, causing delay. It is still not finished, though officials report that no significant issues remain outstanding. But it has missed the statutory deadline by a year.
Meanwhile, some catching up has apparently been going on. Significant progress has been made in concluding the audit for 2024/25 financial year, report officials, and it is anticipated that audit procedures will be completed by the end of February. However, the statutory backstop date of 27 February will not be met.
One of the key problems with the 2024/25 accounts was Middleton Grange shopping centre, says the report to the AGC. It was initially classified as an investment property in the accounts but was subsequently reclassified as Land and Buildings within Property, Plant & Equipment.
Comment
The Conservative government of Rishi Sunak seems to have allowed mayoral development corporations to be set up in both Hartlepool and Middlesbrough without thinking much about whether such comparatively small places had the capacity to run them effectively. It was probably done as a favour to Lord Houchen, his near neighbour as MP for Richmond and in the Tories’ good books at the time.
It would not have taken much thought to realise that just because MDCs were working in London and Greater Manchester and even perhaps at the time apparently in South Tees, it did not mean they could succeed in the two small Teesside boroughs as well. Hartlepool may well need a bail-out from TVCA before the end of March, as reported by NEB here on 26 January, and Middlesbrough MDC’s problems were devastatingly exposed by Ray Casey here on 27 January.





