• Contact
  • About
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
North East Bylines
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • European News
    • Health
    • Politics
    • Science
    • UK News
    • World News
    Tyne Bridge

    Newcastle shortlisted for Eurovision 2023

    Fishing protest

    Dead crustaceans on North East coast: the next chapter

    NUFC foodbank

    Howay the lads and lasses: the new football foodbank season ‘22/23

    Darlington protestors

    Protestors greet Sunak and Truss at Tory Hustings in Darlington

    RMT Union banner

    When do strikes work? History shows the conditions need to be right

    Cartoon of Liz Truss with shopping trolley

    Tory leadership election: policy shopping is no way to treat people

    Border control at Dover

    The moral argument for open borders

    the quilt

    Join Hands for Ukraine at the Royal Albert Hall

    Juárez, Chihuahua, Mexico, 08-06-2021 A man was shot to death in the streets of Juárez, the experts work at the crime scene.

    Mexico: new research shows the historic link between opening schools and falling murder rates

    Trending Tags

    • Ukraine
  • Culture
    • All
    • Animation
    • Books
    • Illustrations & More
    • Music
    • Performance
    • Poetry
    • Social Media
    • Theatre
    • TV & Radio
    Tyne Bridge

    Newcastle shortlisted for Eurovision 2023

    NUFC foodbank

    Howay the lads and lasses: the new football foodbank season ‘22/23

    Summer, Lower East Side. Weegee Ⓒ ICP (International Center of Photography)

    Classic Street Style: Weegee, Doisneau, Forsyth: three cities, three photographers, three decades

    Promo image

    Cutthroat Island: preparing to terrify landlubbers!

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food & Drink
    • Health & Fitness
    Master Chef of Great Britain

    Master Chef of Great Britain at Lumley

    Prezzo

    Discovering the new summer menu at Prezzo

    Chef and son

    MasterChef’s’ Posh Street Food chef’s own summer of entertainment

    Scottish highlands

    The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

    Kleo Tabuku

    Top chef to open Newcastle restaurant, Lovage

    Pop up park

    Pop up to the park in Sunderland

    The Blackbird Inn, Ponteland

    The Blackbird Inn flies high with its new summer menu

    gymnast

    Culture of fear in British gymnastics uncovered by the Whyte Review

    Kennedy and Rhind

    Kennedy and Rhind: more time to enjoy a North East favourite

    Trending Tags

    • Business
      • All
      • Economy
      • Rural
      • Technology
      • Trade
      • Voluntary Sector
      Fishing protest

      Dead crustaceans on North East coast: the next chapter

      Scottish highlands

      The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

      loo

      A room with a loo

      Newcastle quayside

      Newcastle named as one of the best cities for graduates

      Brexit economics

      New research shows the economic effect of Brexit

      Wetherspoons pub

      Wetherspoons sparkle: has it gone flat?

      Leon Fussell rehearsing

      Unsung Heroes at Queen’s Hall, Hexham

      Houchen and spade

      Vampire daylight: a week in the life of Ben Houchen, Tees Valley Mayor

      Keir Starmer

      Open letter to Sir Keir Starmer

      Trending Tags

      • Region
        • All
        • Co. Durham
        • North East
        • Northumberland
        • Teesside
        • Tyneside
        • Wearside
        Tyne Bridge

        Newcastle shortlisted for Eurovision 2023

        Wildfire at Witherwack

        “Busier than Bonfire Night” as wildfire rages for over 20 hours

        Fishing protest

        Dead crustaceans on North East coast: the next chapter

        NUFC foodbank

        Howay the lads and lasses: the new football foodbank season ‘22/23

        Summer, Lower East Side. Weegee Ⓒ ICP (International Center of Photography)

        Classic Street Style: Weegee, Doisneau, Forsyth: three cities, three photographers, three decades

        Darlington protestors

        Protestors greet Sunak and Truss at Tory Hustings in Darlington

        Promo image

        Cutthroat Island: preparing to terrify landlubbers!

        DCFO Peter Heath

        Fire chiefs urge public to behave responsibly amid hot weather warnings

        Pride flag

        Northern Pride: Newcastle proves it’s loud, proud and still fighting

        Trending Tags

        • Opinion
          Titanic coming out of Southampton

          The 110th anniversary of the Titanic’s departure

          There is an England

          There is an England

          Prime Minister Boris Johnson signs the Withdrawal Agreement with the European Union"

          The parody of disinformation: Boris Johnson on Ukraine and Brexit

          Boris Johnson’s comments on Ukraine and Brexit are an insult

          TV Agency staff jumping in the air

          The TV Agency celebrates 10th anniversary with global success

          North East of County Dublin

          North East of England and North East of County Dublin: Compare and contrast

          North Sea oil rig

          Copping out of COP: Ukraine, fossil fuels and nuclear fusion

          Placard with Boris Johnson as a clown

          Dictators, media and mobility: erosion of identity, sustenance and safety

          close up on a child's eye

          Racism and misogyny where there should have been safeguarding and security

        AUDIO
        No Result
        View All Result
        • Home
        • News
          • All
          • Brexit
          • Education
          • Environment
          • European News
          • Health
          • Politics
          • Science
          • UK News
          • World News
          Tyne Bridge

          Newcastle shortlisted for Eurovision 2023

          Fishing protest

          Dead crustaceans on North East coast: the next chapter

          NUFC foodbank

          Howay the lads and lasses: the new football foodbank season ‘22/23

          Darlington protestors

          Protestors greet Sunak and Truss at Tory Hustings in Darlington

          RMT Union banner

          When do strikes work? History shows the conditions need to be right

          Cartoon of Liz Truss with shopping trolley

          Tory leadership election: policy shopping is no way to treat people

          Border control at Dover

          The moral argument for open borders

          the quilt

          Join Hands for Ukraine at the Royal Albert Hall

          Juárez, Chihuahua, Mexico, 08-06-2021 A man was shot to death in the streets of Juárez, the experts work at the crime scene.

          Mexico: new research shows the historic link between opening schools and falling murder rates

          Trending Tags

          • Ukraine
        • Culture
          • All
          • Animation
          • Books
          • Illustrations & More
          • Music
          • Performance
          • Poetry
          • Social Media
          • Theatre
          • TV & Radio
          Tyne Bridge

          Newcastle shortlisted for Eurovision 2023

          NUFC foodbank

          Howay the lads and lasses: the new football foodbank season ‘22/23

          Summer, Lower East Side. Weegee Ⓒ ICP (International Center of Photography)

          Classic Street Style: Weegee, Doisneau, Forsyth: three cities, three photographers, three decades

          Promo image

          Cutthroat Island: preparing to terrify landlubbers!

        • Lifestyle
          • All
          • Fashion
          • Food & Drink
          • Health & Fitness
          Master Chef of Great Britain

          Master Chef of Great Britain at Lumley

          Prezzo

          Discovering the new summer menu at Prezzo

          Chef and son

          MasterChef’s’ Posh Street Food chef’s own summer of entertainment

          Scottish highlands

          The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

          Kleo Tabuku

          Top chef to open Newcastle restaurant, Lovage

          Pop up park

          Pop up to the park in Sunderland

          The Blackbird Inn, Ponteland

          The Blackbird Inn flies high with its new summer menu

          gymnast

          Culture of fear in British gymnastics uncovered by the Whyte Review

          Kennedy and Rhind

          Kennedy and Rhind: more time to enjoy a North East favourite

          Trending Tags

          • Business
            • All
            • Economy
            • Rural
            • Technology
            • Trade
            • Voluntary Sector
            Fishing protest

            Dead crustaceans on North East coast: the next chapter

            Scottish highlands

            The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

            loo

            A room with a loo

            Newcastle quayside

            Newcastle named as one of the best cities for graduates

            Brexit economics

            New research shows the economic effect of Brexit

            Wetherspoons pub

            Wetherspoons sparkle: has it gone flat?

            Leon Fussell rehearsing

            Unsung Heroes at Queen’s Hall, Hexham

            Houchen and spade

            Vampire daylight: a week in the life of Ben Houchen, Tees Valley Mayor

            Keir Starmer

            Open letter to Sir Keir Starmer

            Trending Tags

            • Region
              • All
              • Co. Durham
              • North East
              • Northumberland
              • Teesside
              • Tyneside
              • Wearside
              Tyne Bridge

              Newcastle shortlisted for Eurovision 2023

              Wildfire at Witherwack

              “Busier than Bonfire Night” as wildfire rages for over 20 hours

              Fishing protest

              Dead crustaceans on North East coast: the next chapter

              NUFC foodbank

              Howay the lads and lasses: the new football foodbank season ‘22/23

              Summer, Lower East Side. Weegee Ⓒ ICP (International Center of Photography)

              Classic Street Style: Weegee, Doisneau, Forsyth: three cities, three photographers, three decades

              Darlington protestors

              Protestors greet Sunak and Truss at Tory Hustings in Darlington

              Promo image

              Cutthroat Island: preparing to terrify landlubbers!

              DCFO Peter Heath

              Fire chiefs urge public to behave responsibly amid hot weather warnings

              Pride flag

              Northern Pride: Newcastle proves it’s loud, proud and still fighting

              Trending Tags

              • Opinion
                Titanic coming out of Southampton

                The 110th anniversary of the Titanic’s departure

                There is an England

                There is an England

                Prime Minister Boris Johnson signs the Withdrawal Agreement with the European Union"

                The parody of disinformation: Boris Johnson on Ukraine and Brexit

                Boris Johnson’s comments on Ukraine and Brexit are an insult

                TV Agency staff jumping in the air

                The TV Agency celebrates 10th anniversary with global success

                North East of County Dublin

                North East of England and North East of County Dublin: Compare and contrast

                North Sea oil rig

                Copping out of COP: Ukraine, fossil fuels and nuclear fusion

                Placard with Boris Johnson as a clown

                Dictators, media and mobility: erosion of identity, sustenance and safety

                close up on a child's eye

                Racism and misogyny where there should have been safeguarding and security

              No Result
              View All Result
              North East Bylines
              No Result
              View All Result
              Home News Brexit

              The fallacy of the sovereignty argument

              We are a sovereign state, and we remained one when a member of the EU. And the surest demonstration of this is that we have left the EU.

              Gareth KearnsbyGareth Kearns
              22-09-2020 20:04
              in Brexit, Politics, UK, World News
              crown

              Photo by Marcus Spiske from unsplash

              Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
              ADVERTISEMENT
              Audio version of this article.

              Boris Johnson has sought, he claims, to have asserted the sovereignty of the UK by means of the curious strategy of breaking an international treaty and, as a final flourish, placing The Executive (the government) above the oversight of the Judiciary, thus trashing a constitutional cornerstone known as ‘the balance of powers’, that has framed our public life since 1688.

              Sovereignty has often been cited as the imperative that demands we leave the European Union. It is said that to be a sovereign state we cannot be a member of the EU. 

              But what is ‘sovereignty’?

              Sovereignty refers to the place where ultimate authority and power is vested. Which, in olden times of yore was, well, the sovereign. It tends not to be in modern times. Other institutions bear the sovereignty of a nation in this day and age. In the UK our constitution vests sovereignty in parliament (oh, and sovereignty never has been, never will be, vested in ‘the people’ because that would be a nonsense indistinguishable from anarchy if ever actually realised. Whenever you see this claimed by a nation it is always the beard for a totalitarian regime – see the various communist states of the last century or indeed, North Korea today, all of which claim or claimed that the people are sovereign).

              To have sovereignty is to be self-governing, for a state to recognize no higher authority.

              Now, you might suppose I just made the case against the EU, but I haven’t. We are a sovereign state, and we remained one when a member of the EU. And the surest demonstration of this is that we have left the EU. If we weren’t a sovereign state, and were in fact subject to the EU, how could we ever choose to leave it? Just think that one through, because the logic there is absolutely watertight. If we were not sovereign we wouldn’t have the power to leave the EU.

              But we’ve chosen to leave the EU. We have left. We’re out. We had the power to do that. Thus, we were always a sovereign state. QED.

              Some say that the EU wouldn’t let us do some things, or required we do others. And this shows that we weren’t sovereign. 

              In practice states compromise sovereignty all the time. And they do so because sovereignty is something much more important and useful than being the king of you. It is the very currency by means of which good neighbourliness between states is bought…

              Here’s an example, avoiding the EU for the time being: NATO. You’ll be aware, I hope, that a key treaty obligation of being a member of NATO is to regard an attack upon one member state as an attack upon all members of NATO. So, if Russia marches into Estonia we, the UK, are obliged to fight Russia back (with all the other members, of course).

              Now, before we go any further, let’s examine the language I just used. The word ‘obliged’.

              If a sovereign state is subject to none, how can it have obligations? If you’re the king of you, you are obliged to no one. That’s watertight logic too. 

              The answer to this apparent contradiction is that a state chooses to assume obligations in return for benefits. Other sovereign states undertake reciprocal obligations. It’s a quid pro quo. And that is what a treaty is. Sovereign states with the power to do whatever the hell they like, agreeing that they will not do whatever the hell they like in certain circumstances. 


              A sovereign state may, of course, pull the nuclear option and withdraw from a treaty at the drop of a hat. They’re sovereign, they can do that. There are always legal mechanisms of withdrawal, and to activate them is fine. There will be due process, all members will know what’s happening, not a problem. However, let’s say that Russia invades Estonia and all the NATO members muster their defence – but Britain decides to just cry off, leaving the rest of NATO in the lurch. Britain can do that – it’s a sovereign state. But then Britain’s word is mud. Then the other states need not respect Britain’s borders, its laws, its people. Why would they bother? There is no hope of any benefit to be won by respecting the integrity of Britain, because there is no reason to trust that the favour will be reciprocated. Britain is trash, with no standing, no meaning. If such a nation wants to live hermetically sealed within its own borders they might be ok, for a given value of ok, as long as all the other nations decide they can’t be bothered to invade. And if some other country does wake up one morning and thinks to itself that invasion and rape of Britain’s resources would be a bit of a wheeze, Britain has no friends to turn to. 

              The nearest thing we have to such a state on the planet right now is North Korea. People starve in North Korea. North Korea does not work. North Korea has nothing holding its Executive in check, and thus other countries do not trust it. Much of its money is spent on its army, which is protecting that Executive, not the people. Sure, we here in the UK have the Executive, the Legislature and the Judiciary, the three pillars, to hold each other in check – oh! But that’s right! Boris Johnson’s regime has put forward a bill that ends that balanced relationship, which makes the Executive exempt from the review of the Judiciary. This effectively amounts to the Executive stealing the Legislature’s sovereignty. It dismantles a fundamental mechanism at the heart of our constitution which has also been adopted by many other states’ constitutions, and for which the foundations were laid back in the 1200s in Magna Carta. 

              Boris Johnson seeks to ditch this fundamental of our constitution. Clause 45 of the Internal Market Bill exempts ministerial decisions from review by the judiciary. And other aspects of the Bill empower ministers to break treaty agreements with the EU. The executive may rule by decree. Which, by definition, is not democracy. 

              But Britain is exposed in an especially invidious way by this cavalier trashing of our constitution. All constitutions are ultimately operations of trust. Ours is old. It was deemed by many to be one of the most secure. Labyrinthine, convoluted and ridded with anachronism, yes, but, in a way, that has added to the security people felt they could invest in it. You’d surely need to launch a very intricate attack to undermine it, or so many believed. Thus, British law is nominated by many multinationals as the jurisdiction for any breaches, challenges or complaints, and has been the insurance law on the high seas for centuries. Our Executive or Legislature undermining our law potentially loses us this massive advantage internationally. Which is why no one, until now, has sought to mess with it. There was, therefore, pressure from within the UK via the balance of powers, and from without via that reputation, to keep us clean, keep us balanced, keep us free.

              Or there was until some Eton boys cried “bah – piffle humbug!” and decided to undermine the constitution to which much of the world refers as the basis for their own constitutions. And so the happy illusion that there was something sacrosanct, something that might always be trusted, some rock hard basis for the institutions that preserve the rule of law and protect a people’s freedoms, has been demolished. 

              Seriously, the implications of this go far beyond any local difficulties regarding the EU. That’s almost incidental. 

              Sovereignty is an absolute legal principle but in practice it is always being traded. Every day. All over the world. It’s normal. Quid pro quo. Mutual back scratching a go-go. That transaction of sovereignty between nations is the very glue that allows states to co-exist, and, when you have a democracy, supports and nourishes that democracy.

              Now, to the EU. It’s a body forged by treaty, no different to NATO. It’s nothing special. Obligations are assumed in return for duties to us being observed. It is nothing to be scared of, it is nothing new. If we pull out we will simply rebuild again pretty much the same the obligations and duties we have had whilst in the EU with all of the rest of the world, only less efficiently and more expensively, and spend decades doing so.

              There are matters of democratic deficit that I’m happy to concede exist with the EU. The fact that there are problems means there are things to be fixed. But the objection to the EU in terms of sovereignty is a red herring promulgated by people who rely upon the ignorance of most of the population as to what the word actually means, and how it operates in practice.

              There is no problem with our sovereignty in relation to the EU, unless you insist on it as an absolute, and if you do that you are running counter to the lived history of all human civilization.

              ADVERTISEMENT
              Previous Post

              Don’t miss the Highlights

              Next Post

              Quoth the raven, “Nevermore!”

              Gareth Kearns

              Gareth Kearns

              Gareth Kearns regularly protests outside parliament, and occasionally around the country, with Steve Bray and SODEM. Not very politically active prior to Brexit, it now seems necessary to put life on hold to resist the rise of fascism in the UK.

              Related Posts

              Fishing protest
              Business

              Dead crustaceans on North East coast: the next chapter

              byJulia Mazza
              August 11, 2022
              NUFC foodbank
              Culture

              Howay the lads and lasses: the new football foodbank season ‘22/23

              byBill Corcoran
              August 10, 2022
              Darlington protestors
              North East

              Protestors greet Sunak and Truss at Tory Hustings in Darlington

              byYvonne Wancke
              August 10, 2022
              RMT Union banner
              Politics

              When do strikes work? History shows the conditions need to be right

              byChristopher Massey
              August 9, 2022
              Cartoon of Liz Truss with shopping trolley
              Opinion

              Tory leadership election: policy shopping is no way to treat people

              byPeter Benson
              August 4, 2022
              Next Post
              Blencathra

              Quoth the raven, “Nevermore!”

              Want to support us?

              Can you help North East Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

              DONATE

              Sign up to our newsletter

              If you would like to receive the North East Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

              NEWSLETTER

              LATEST

              Tyne Bridge

              Newcastle shortlisted for Eurovision 2023

              August 12, 2022
              Wildfire at Witherwack

              “Busier than Bonfire Night” as wildfire rages for over 20 hours

              August 11, 2022
              Fishing protest

              Dead crustaceans on North East coast: the next chapter

              August 11, 2022
              NUFC foodbank

              Howay the lads and lasses: the new football foodbank season ‘22/23

              August 10, 2022
              Summer, Lower East Side. Weegee Ⓒ ICP (International Center of Photography)

              Classic Street Style: Weegee, Doisneau, Forsyth: three cities, three photographers, three decades

              August 10, 2022
              Darlington protestors

              Protestors greet Sunak and Truss at Tory Hustings in Darlington

              August 10, 2022

              MOST READ

              Tyne Bridge

              Newcastle shortlisted for Eurovision 2023

              August 12, 2022
              Wildfire at Witherwack

              “Busier than Bonfire Night” as wildfire rages for over 20 hours

              August 11, 2022
              Fishing protest

              Dead crustaceans on North East coast: the next chapter

              August 11, 2022
              NUFC foodbank

              Howay the lads and lasses: the new football foodbank season ‘22/23

              August 10, 2022

              BROWSE BY TAGS

              Audio Beach Brexit Business castle leazes climate activism Co. Durham cost of living crisis Culture defra democracy ducklings Economy Education Environment fire and rescue firefighter Food & Drink food poverty Health Health & Care Home Affairs just stop oil Lifestyle Local Lockdown Northumberland Peace Performance Politics pride month refugee rescue Science Social Media Teesside TV & Radio Tynemouth Tyneside Ukraine volunteer Wearside

              We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in the North East and beyond.

              North East Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Network Limited, which is a sister organisation to Byline Times.

              Learn more about us

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Contact
              • About
              • Letters
              • Donate
              • Privacy
              • Bylines network
              • Shop

              © 2022 North East Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Home
              • News
                • Brexit
                • Education
                • Environment
                • UK News
                • Transport
                • World News
              • Politics
              • Opinion
              • Lifestyle
                • Culture
                • Music
                • Poetry
              • Business
                • Economy
                • Technology
                • Trade
              • Donate
              • Newsletter sign up
              • Boriiis Cartoons
              • Authors
              • Audio

              © 2022 North East Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              Welcome Back!

              Login to your account below

              Forgotten Password?

              Retrieve your password

              Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

              Log In