• Contact
  • About
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
North East Bylines
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • European News
    • Health
    • Politics
    • Science
    • UK News
    • World News
    man looking anxious

    Never assume: honesty and mental health

    Flood in York in 2022. Climate change brings about more floods and not just heatwaves and wildfires

    The Tories’ climate change policy does not add up

    A sign with the "not equal" symbol is held in a crowd

    Inequality and development: from global to local

    South Tyneside's only black electric taxi

    A sustainable policy for Tyneside taxis

    Ben Houchen by Scott Hunter

    Alleged National Audit Office review of Teesworks

    Child poverty protestor

    Child poverty: enough is enough

    Boys with kite in Kabul

    One year since the fall of Afghanistan

    North East for Europe at an earlier London march

    The North East in London for National Rejoin March

    Tyne Bridge

    Newcastle shortlisted for Eurovision 2023

    Trending Tags

    • Ukraine
  • Culture
    • All
    • Animation
    • Books
    • Illustrations & More
    • Music
    • Performance
    • Poetry
    • Social Media
    • Theatre
    • TV & Radio
    The Rock Showman

    Hardwick Festival is down with the kids

    Witty Look

    All aboard the festival bus for Hardwick this weekend

    Boys with kite in Kabul

    One year since the fall of Afghanistan

    Eurovision sign

    The North East could host Eurovision in 2023

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food & Drink
    • Health & Fitness
    Master Chef of Great Britain

    Master Chef of Great Britain at Lumley

    Prezzo

    Discovering the new summer menu at Prezzo

    Chef and son

    MasterChef’s’ Posh Street Food chef’s own summer of entertainment

    Scottish highlands

    The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

    Kleo Tabuku

    Top chef to open Newcastle restaurant, Lovage

    Pop up park

    Pop up to the park in Sunderland

    The Blackbird Inn, Ponteland

    The Blackbird Inn flies high with its new summer menu

    gymnast

    Culture of fear in British gymnastics uncovered by the Whyte Review

    Kennedy and Rhind

    Kennedy and Rhind: more time to enjoy a North East favourite

    Trending Tags

    • Business
      • All
      • Economy
      • Rural
      • Technology
      • Trade
      • Voluntary Sector
      Ben Houchen by Scott Hunter

      Alleged National Audit Office review of Teesworks

      Fishing protest

      Dead crustaceans on North East coast: the next chapter

      Scottish highlands

      The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

      loo

      A room with a loo

      Newcastle quayside

      Newcastle named as one of the best cities for graduates

      Brexit economics

      New research shows the economic effect of Brexit

      Wetherspoons pub

      Wetherspoons sparkle: has it gone flat?

      Leon Fussell rehearsing

      Unsung Heroes at Queen’s Hall, Hexham

      Houchen and spade

      Vampire daylight: a week in the life of Ben Houchen, Tees Valley Mayor

      Trending Tags

      • Region
        • All
        • Co. Durham
        • North East
        • Northumberland
        • Teesside
        • Tyneside
        • Wearside
        A sign with the "not equal" symbol is held in a crowd

        Inequality and development: from global to local

        South Tyneside's only black electric taxi

        A sustainable policy for Tyneside taxis

        Ben Houchen by Scott Hunter

        Alleged National Audit Office review of Teesworks

        Child poverty protestor

        Child poverty: enough is enough

        Tyne Bridge

        Newcastle shortlisted for Eurovision 2023

        Wildfire at Witherwack

        “Busier than Bonfire Night” as wildfire rages for over 20 hours

        Fishing protest

        Dead crustaceans on North East coast: the next chapter

        NUFC foodbank

        Howay the lads and lasses: the new football foodbank season ‘22/23

        Summer, Lower East Side. Weegee Ⓒ ICP (International Center of Photography)

        Classic Street Style: Weegee, Doisneau, Forsyth: three cities, three photographers, three decades

        Trending Tags

        • Opinion
          Titanic coming out of Southampton

          The 110th anniversary of the Titanic’s departure

          There is an England

          There is an England

          Prime Minister Boris Johnson signs the Withdrawal Agreement with the European Union"

          The parody of disinformation: Boris Johnson on Ukraine and Brexit

          Boris Johnson’s comments on Ukraine and Brexit are an insult

          TV Agency staff jumping in the air

          The TV Agency celebrates 10th anniversary with global success

          North East of County Dublin

          North East of England and North East of County Dublin: Compare and contrast

          North Sea oil rig

          Copping out of COP: Ukraine, fossil fuels and nuclear fusion

          Placard with Boris Johnson as a clown

          Dictators, media and mobility: erosion of identity, sustenance and safety

          close up on a child's eye

          Racism and misogyny where there should have been safeguarding and security

        AUDIO
        No Result
        View All Result
        • Home
        • News
          • All
          • Brexit
          • Education
          • Environment
          • European News
          • Health
          • Politics
          • Science
          • UK News
          • World News
          man looking anxious

          Never assume: honesty and mental health

          Flood in York in 2022. Climate change brings about more floods and not just heatwaves and wildfires

          The Tories’ climate change policy does not add up

          A sign with the "not equal" symbol is held in a crowd

          Inequality and development: from global to local

          South Tyneside's only black electric taxi

          A sustainable policy for Tyneside taxis

          Ben Houchen by Scott Hunter

          Alleged National Audit Office review of Teesworks

          Child poverty protestor

          Child poverty: enough is enough

          Boys with kite in Kabul

          One year since the fall of Afghanistan

          North East for Europe at an earlier London march

          The North East in London for National Rejoin March

          Tyne Bridge

          Newcastle shortlisted for Eurovision 2023

          Trending Tags

          • Ukraine
        • Culture
          • All
          • Animation
          • Books
          • Illustrations & More
          • Music
          • Performance
          • Poetry
          • Social Media
          • Theatre
          • TV & Radio
          The Rock Showman

          Hardwick Festival is down with the kids

          Witty Look

          All aboard the festival bus for Hardwick this weekend

          Boys with kite in Kabul

          One year since the fall of Afghanistan

          Eurovision sign

          The North East could host Eurovision in 2023

        • Lifestyle
          • All
          • Fashion
          • Food & Drink
          • Health & Fitness
          Master Chef of Great Britain

          Master Chef of Great Britain at Lumley

          Prezzo

          Discovering the new summer menu at Prezzo

          Chef and son

          MasterChef’s’ Posh Street Food chef’s own summer of entertainment

          Scottish highlands

          The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

          Kleo Tabuku

          Top chef to open Newcastle restaurant, Lovage

          Pop up park

          Pop up to the park in Sunderland

          The Blackbird Inn, Ponteland

          The Blackbird Inn flies high with its new summer menu

          gymnast

          Culture of fear in British gymnastics uncovered by the Whyte Review

          Kennedy and Rhind

          Kennedy and Rhind: more time to enjoy a North East favourite

          Trending Tags

          • Business
            • All
            • Economy
            • Rural
            • Technology
            • Trade
            • Voluntary Sector
            Ben Houchen by Scott Hunter

            Alleged National Audit Office review of Teesworks

            Fishing protest

            Dead crustaceans on North East coast: the next chapter

            Scottish highlands

            The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

            loo

            A room with a loo

            Newcastle quayside

            Newcastle named as one of the best cities for graduates

            Brexit economics

            New research shows the economic effect of Brexit

            Wetherspoons pub

            Wetherspoons sparkle: has it gone flat?

            Leon Fussell rehearsing

            Unsung Heroes at Queen’s Hall, Hexham

            Houchen and spade

            Vampire daylight: a week in the life of Ben Houchen, Tees Valley Mayor

            Trending Tags

            • Region
              • All
              • Co. Durham
              • North East
              • Northumberland
              • Teesside
              • Tyneside
              • Wearside
              A sign with the "not equal" symbol is held in a crowd

              Inequality and development: from global to local

              South Tyneside's only black electric taxi

              A sustainable policy for Tyneside taxis

              Ben Houchen by Scott Hunter

              Alleged National Audit Office review of Teesworks

              Child poverty protestor

              Child poverty: enough is enough

              Tyne Bridge

              Newcastle shortlisted for Eurovision 2023

              Wildfire at Witherwack

              “Busier than Bonfire Night” as wildfire rages for over 20 hours

              Fishing protest

              Dead crustaceans on North East coast: the next chapter

              NUFC foodbank

              Howay the lads and lasses: the new football foodbank season ‘22/23

              Summer, Lower East Side. Weegee Ⓒ ICP (International Center of Photography)

              Classic Street Style: Weegee, Doisneau, Forsyth: three cities, three photographers, three decades

              Trending Tags

              • Opinion
                Titanic coming out of Southampton

                The 110th anniversary of the Titanic’s departure

                There is an England

                There is an England

                Prime Minister Boris Johnson signs the Withdrawal Agreement with the European Union"

                The parody of disinformation: Boris Johnson on Ukraine and Brexit

                Boris Johnson’s comments on Ukraine and Brexit are an insult

                TV Agency staff jumping in the air

                The TV Agency celebrates 10th anniversary with global success

                North East of County Dublin

                North East of England and North East of County Dublin: Compare and contrast

                North Sea oil rig

                Copping out of COP: Ukraine, fossil fuels and nuclear fusion

                Placard with Boris Johnson as a clown

                Dictators, media and mobility: erosion of identity, sustenance and safety

                close up on a child's eye

                Racism and misogyny where there should have been safeguarding and security

              No Result
              View All Result
              North East Bylines
              No Result
              View All Result
              Home News Brexit

              Gordon Brown, the Scotland problem and the tale of two Brexits

              While the Libertarian ideology of Cummings and his associates does not exclude Scotland per se, parts of England’s electorate do.

              Scott HunterbyScott Hunter
              22-12-2020 12:15
              in Brexit, Politics, UK
              Gordon Brown two Brexits

              Photo by Adam Wilson on Unsplash

              Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
              ADVERTISEMENT

              While the rest of us continue to navigate the global pandemic, and await a possible no-deal Brexit, former Prime Minister Gordon Brown chose recently to write about the unifying effect of devolution across the UK.  Despite appearances to the contrary, it was well timed.  While the pandemic is severe, it is also (hopefully) short term.  The need for ‘levelling up’ the regions on the other hand, is both urgent and long term.  And this government came to power on the promise to extend English devolution, in a way that had hitherto been anathema to Conservatives.

              A few days later Brown published a second article,  to coincide with devolution being declared a disaster by Boris Johnson.  Did he manage to deliver a stinging rebuke?  No, the whole piece was in actual fact oddly irrelevant.

              He laments a rise in the popularity of separatism in Scotland, explains why English regions need a Barnett-style formula to create a robust basis for devolution, and advocates the setting up of citizen assemblies to reset the political consensus.

              He thus skirts delicately round two key issues that should, in fact, have exercised his mind – one is Brexit (it is mentioned only once), the other is the fact that, since the Independence vote in 2014, support for Labour in Scotland has collapsed.  The latter being a matter about which the UK Labour Party as a whole remains steadfastly incurious.  Time, perhaps, to have a good look at these, as they bear on the conclusions he draws about devolution.

              No sooner had Brown left office in 2010, than we entered the age of the plebiscite – three referenda in six years, beginning with the AV referendum in 2011.  This is important because of the strategy then Prime Minister David Cameron employed to secure victory – give those who advocate electoral reform a platform, but not the proposed reform they actually believe in.  They lose, the status quo is maintained, job done.

              Cameron, flushed with success, employs the same tactic for the Scottish Independence referendum – insist on the most disruptive form of Independence for Scotland being on the ballot, and leave the Scottish National Party (SNP) to struggle to sell it to the electorate.  He then experienced the inherent problem of plebiscites, which is that political parties do not control them.  The public does.  Ed Miliband, for one, failed to grasp this fact, and belatedly went on the attack against the SNP.  He had no idea that the SNP, while on the same side as the ‘Yes’ supporters, was only a part of the picture.  The SNP was providing fuel, but the arguments were being had in every house, bar, school and workplace in the country.  And it was there that opinion was being moulded.  Gordon Brown, in turn, has failed to appreciate that opinion expressed by plebiscite is different from policy ratified at party conference.  Politicians don’t have the means to alter it.

              The Labour Party paid the price in subsequent elections, but still Gordon Brown continues to dismiss any separatist perspective as ‘grievance politics’.  It’s odd, however, that while he is critical of separatism in Scotland, he offers no opinion on the inherent separatism of Brexit.  Brexit, it seems, is a decision made.  We just have to get on with it.

              From my perspective, however, there are two Brexits to deal with – the Libertarianism of Vote Leave, on the one hand, and the Rule-Britannia-end-immigration-the-EU-costs-a-fortune-and-we-don’t-get-nothing-back-black-is-white nativism of England’s Brexit-supporting public on the other.  As with the Scottish referendum, the campaign leaders fuelled the debate, but did not control it.  Thus, Vote Leave won with there being very limited discussion among the public at large about the Libertarian project.  The electorate owns its own Brexit.  And Brown appears to think the Scottish electorate is about to just suck it up.

              Brown describes at length what he considers the real priorities of Scottish voters: “60% of Scots say the different nations of the UK still have more in common than divides us”, a majority view not just from those close to the Border but from the Highlands and the Industrial Central Belt. Even more say they feel strong affinity with England’s North and Midlands, and with Wales. And a bigger proportion, 76%, say “the UK and Scottish governments should be better at cooperating on issues affecting my life”. Hardly a plea for separation (quotes are original, Brown does not identify their source).

              So what’s wrong with that? 

              What’s wrong with it is that he fails to observe that the sentiment is not mutual.  In Brexitworld, politics is hyper-partisan; sceptics are quislings and enemies of the people.  Compare Brown’s comments to these, found below the line of a recent Mail-online article:

               “Frankly, put the Scottish devolution bid to the English and the Welsh to vote for and there would be a resounding ‘Get Lost’, please go and leave us in peace and then watch them die economically.” 

              Now it would be unwarranted to deduce from the opinion of a single bigot, the mindset of English Brexiters as a whole, but we have all seen comments like this before; in recent years applied in equal measure to the people of Scotland and Northern Ireland.  So, while the Libertarian ideology of Cummings and his associates does not exclude Scotland per se, parts of England’s electorate do.


              • Otherworld
              • Britain and Ireland: a shared history
              • A mind to extend
              • Private schools lie at the root of the UK’s inequalities
              • The government needs to do more to save the High Street: a response to the Arcadia administration news

              The choice facing the people of Scotland is a stark one.  If they concede that separation from the UK will have so damaging an effect on their economy that the retention of the Union is preferable, then they are obliged to submit to this government’s Libertarian agenda, and tolerate the ongoing hostility of England’s Brexiters.  The alternative is to demand Independence from the UK, which will be so unwelcome at Westminster, that we can expect that the most severe of separations to result (let’s face it, ‘benign’ and ‘Boris Johnson’ rarely appear in the same sentence).  On the presumption that Scotland then re-joins the EU, it will trade with the UK on whatever deal is struck now between Johnson’s government and Brussels.  As Scotland relies on trade with the UK more than any other nation in Europe, it stands to be the most adversely affected by that deal.  But will Scotland’s separatists achieve their goal?

              Separatist movements elsewhere, Quebec in particular, have struggled to attract majority support.  One place where it has succeeded, however, is Southern Sudan.  And there are two key features of the separation there that bear on the Scottish case.  One is that, like Scotland, the movement was strictly separatist and not nativist-nationalist, and secondly that the racist attitudes of people in Northern Sudan meant that it was widely supported there by people in both regions.  Push as well as pull.

              For those in England who believe that Brexit will bring with it economic catastrophe, and that Scotland’s economy will eventually be the more robust for EU membership, there remains the question of whether, in the end, England also has something to gain from the separation.  For Brexiters there’s the satisfaction of ‘we’re better off without them’.  For anti-Brexiters there’s a more subtle advantage, which is that in a world of hyper-partisan politics, giving your opponents everything they wish for reduces the number of scapegoats they have at their disposal when things go pear-shaped.

              At present there is no evidence that the popularity of Brexit is diminished (and recent popular support for cutting the UK’s international aid budget mirrors that).

              If, as many believe, Brexit will be much less damaging to the EU than it will be to the UK, we can envisage a situation where there is economic growth in Scotland and economic decline in England. It becomes much harder for Brexiters to deny that Brexit is the underlying cause of that decline when the EU is on England’s northern Border, rather than across the Channel and the Irish Sea.

              This does not emerge from Gordon Brown’s interpretation, because of its basic assumptions and its top-down perspective – the Union is good, and Brexit’s a done deal whose worst effects can be alleviated by reforming structures of governance.  In reality, the threat that Scottish Independence poses to Brexit is not to be underestimated.  And as Brexit remains the defining political shift of our times, no discussion of political reform can justifiably ignore it. 

              ADVERTISEMENT
              Previous Post

              New poll: Brexit transition needed as transport crisis deepens

              Next Post

              First commons debate on Long Covid is secured by Layla Moran MP

              Scott Hunter

              Scott Hunter

              Related Posts

              Flood in York in 2022. Climate change brings about more floods and not just heatwaves and wildfires
              Brexit

              The Tories’ climate change policy does not add up

              byGiuseppe Bignardi
              August 18, 2022
              A sign with the "not equal" symbol is held in a crowd
              North East

              Inequality and development: from global to local

              bySophie Lively
              August 17, 2022
              Ben Houchen by Scott Hunter
              Business

              Alleged National Audit Office review of Teesworks

              byScott Hunter
              August 16, 2022
              Child poverty protestor
              North East

              Child poverty: enough is enough

              byPeter Benson
              August 15, 2022
              Boys with kite in Kabul
              Culture

              One year since the fall of Afghanistan

              byCarol Westall
              August 15, 2022
              Next Post
              House of Commons

              First commons debate on Long Covid is secured by Layla Moran MP

              Want to support us?

              Can you help North East Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

              DONATE

              Sign up to our newsletter

              If you would like to receive the North East Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

              NEWSLETTER

              LATEST

              man looking anxious

              Never assume: honesty and mental health

              August 18, 2022
              Flood in York in 2022. Climate change brings about more floods and not just heatwaves and wildfires

              The Tories’ climate change policy does not add up

              August 18, 2022
              A sign with the "not equal" symbol is held in a crowd

              Inequality and development: from global to local

              August 17, 2022
              South Tyneside's only black electric taxi

              A sustainable policy for Tyneside taxis

              August 17, 2022
              The Rock Showman

              Hardwick Festival is down with the kids

              August 17, 2022
              Ben Houchen by Scott Hunter

              Alleged National Audit Office review of Teesworks

              August 16, 2022

              MOST READ

              man looking anxious

              Never assume: honesty and mental health

              August 18, 2022
              Flood in York in 2022. Climate change brings about more floods and not just heatwaves and wildfires

              The Tories’ climate change policy does not add up

              August 18, 2022
              A sign with the "not equal" symbol is held in a crowd

              Inequality and development: from global to local

              August 17, 2022
              South Tyneside's only black electric taxi

              A sustainable policy for Tyneside taxis

              August 17, 2022

              BROWSE BY TAGS

              Audio Beach Brexit Business castle leazes climate activism Co. Durham cost of living crisis Culture defra democracy ducklings Economy Education Environment fire and rescue firefighter Food & Drink food poverty Health Health & Care Home Affairs just stop oil Lifestyle Local Lockdown Northumberland Peace Performance Politics pride month refugee rescue Science Social Media Teesside TV & Radio Tynemouth Tyneside Ukraine volunteer Wearside

              We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in the North East and beyond.

              North East Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Network Limited, which is a sister organisation to Byline Times.

              Learn more about us

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Contact
              • About
              • Letters
              • Donate
              • Privacy
              • Bylines network
              • Shop

              © 2022 North East Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Home
              • News
                • Brexit
                • Education
                • Environment
                • UK News
                • Transport
                • World News
              • Politics
              • Opinion
              • Lifestyle
                • Culture
                • Music
                • Poetry
              • Business
                • Economy
                • Technology
                • Trade
              • Donate
              • Newsletter sign up
              • Boriiis Cartoons
              • Authors
              • Audio

              © 2022 North East Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              Welcome Back!

              Login to your account below

              Forgotten Password?

              Retrieve your password

              Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

              Log In