• Contact
  • About
  • Authors
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
North East Bylines
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • European News
    • Health
    • Politics
    • Science
    • UK News
    • World News
    "Molly Scott Cato in Bristol" by Bristol Green Party is marked with CC0 1.0.

    Government loses sight of climate crisis as energy windfall tax encourages rise in fossil fuel investment

    Silhouette of family

    Cost of living crisis: a fundamental rethink is needed to support families in the North East

    American flag with gun, apple and pencils

    A star spangled lullaby

    Map showing British Empire in 1886

    Three imperial policies that still influence life in Britain today

    Anna Bird CEO EMUK

    European Movement describes failures of leadership and a toxic culture at the centre of Number 10

    Civic Centre, Hartlepool

    Hartlepool Tories attend council meeting despite declaration of a boycott in the Cranney case

    Fishing protest

    Troubled waters: the forces behind the death of the Tees

    Georgian flag

    The British Isles and Georgia: opposite corners of Europe connected

    Women wearing surgical masks 1919

    Spanish flu: the mother of all pandemics

    Trending Tags

    • Ukraine
  • Culture
    • All
    • Animation
    • Books
    • Illustrations & More
    • Music
    • Performance
    • Poetry
    • Social Media
    • Theatre
    • TV & Radio
    A way home promo photo

    A Way Home: the true story of Durham’s category ‘D’ villages brought to life in new play

    American flag with gun, apple and pencils

    A star spangled lullaby

    Georgian flag

    The British Isles and Georgia: opposite corners of Europe connected

    Three Tall Women

    Three Tall Women at the People’s Theatre

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food & Drink
    • Health & Fitness
    Meat feast pizza

    Bella Italia launches new menu

    Ukrainian necklace

    Ukrainian Cultural Heritage: jewellery, accessories and some morale boosting art

    Leek and mushroom bake

    Leek and mushroom bake

    Byker children in community planting

    Byker Community Planting: growing food in a safe space in the city

    Ukrainian embroidery from Goodz

    Ukrainian Vyshyvanka: traditional embroidery

    Helen Hrynenko in traditional Ukrainian dress

    Ukrainian fashion: getting ready for Vyshyvanka Day

    Chana Bhuna

    Chana Bhuna

    dal

    Dal: delicious with yoghurt and chapatis

    chia seeds

    Chia egg cake

    Trending Tags

    • Business
      • All
      • Economy
      • Rural
      • Technology
      • Voluntary Sector
      Fishing protest

      Troubled waters: the forces behind the death of the Tees

      Renault Twizy

      Driving in style with my Renault Twizy

      office with computers

      Cyber-attacks, ransomware and the dark web

      man working from home in bed

      Is working from home good for business?

      Greggs coffee cup

      Tales from Greggs: celebrating a North East business

      Cold hands on radiator

      Fuel poverty is a serious problem for the North East

      Hannah Hauxwell in documentary Too long a Winter

      Hannah Hauxwell: How an isolated daleswoman became a national icon

      Message about Universal Basic Income

      Universal basic income: a moral necessity

      Job interview

      Hiring friends and family might actually be good for business says new research

      Trending Tags

      • Region
        • All
        • Co. Durham
        • North East
        • Northumberland
        • Teesside
        • Tyneside
        • Wearside
        Jack Charlton

        The Irish Ambassador honours Jack Charlton with a Presidential Award

        Silhouette of family

        Cost of living crisis: a fundamental rethink is needed to support families in the North East

        Civic Centre, Hartlepool

        Hartlepool Tories attend council meeting despite declaration of a boycott in the Cranney case

        Father and child in Newcastle

        Newcastle ranks among Europe’s top 20 cities for raising children

        Refugees welcome sign

        Tyneside groups pledge to carry on fight against government’s anti-refugee laws

        Jimmy Carter saying Howay the lads to the crowd with Jim Callaghan to his left and the lord mayor, Hugh White is just behind him.

        Time to remember the 45th anniversary of American President Jimmy Carter’s visit to Newcastle

        Open day with the fire service at South Shields

        A peek behind the fire curtain with TWFRS at South Shields open day

        Seaham Conservative Club

        ‘Death match’ wrestling at Seaham Conservative Club is under investigation

        Richard Holden

        Richard Holden, MP and Beergate: those who live by the smear fall by the same

        Trending Tags

        • Opinion
          Titanic coming out of Southampton

          The 110th anniversary of the Titanic’s departure

          There is an England

          There is an England

          Prime Minister Boris Johnson signs the Withdrawal Agreement with the European Union"

          The parody of disinformation: Boris Johnson on Ukraine and Brexit

          Boris Johnson’s comments on Ukraine and Brexit are an insult

          TV Agency staff jumping in the air

          The TV Agency celebrates 10th anniversary with global success

          North East of County Dublin

          North East of England and North East of County Dublin: Compare and contrast

          North Sea oil rig

          Copping out of COP: Ukraine, fossil fuels and nuclear fusion

          Placard with Boris Johnson as a clown

          Dictators, media and mobility: erosion of identity, sustenance and safety

          close up on a child's eye

          Racism and misogyny where there should have been safeguarding and security

        No Result
        View All Result
        • Home
        • News
          • All
          • Brexit
          • Education
          • Environment
          • European News
          • Health
          • Politics
          • Science
          • UK News
          • World News
          "Molly Scott Cato in Bristol" by Bristol Green Party is marked with CC0 1.0.

          Government loses sight of climate crisis as energy windfall tax encourages rise in fossil fuel investment

          Silhouette of family

          Cost of living crisis: a fundamental rethink is needed to support families in the North East

          American flag with gun, apple and pencils

          A star spangled lullaby

          Map showing British Empire in 1886

          Three imperial policies that still influence life in Britain today

          Anna Bird CEO EMUK

          European Movement describes failures of leadership and a toxic culture at the centre of Number 10

          Civic Centre, Hartlepool

          Hartlepool Tories attend council meeting despite declaration of a boycott in the Cranney case

          Fishing protest

          Troubled waters: the forces behind the death of the Tees

          Georgian flag

          The British Isles and Georgia: opposite corners of Europe connected

          Women wearing surgical masks 1919

          Spanish flu: the mother of all pandemics

          Trending Tags

          • Ukraine
        • Culture
          • All
          • Animation
          • Books
          • Illustrations & More
          • Music
          • Performance
          • Poetry
          • Social Media
          • Theatre
          • TV & Radio
          A way home promo photo

          A Way Home: the true story of Durham’s category ‘D’ villages brought to life in new play

          American flag with gun, apple and pencils

          A star spangled lullaby

          Georgian flag

          The British Isles and Georgia: opposite corners of Europe connected

          Three Tall Women

          Three Tall Women at the People’s Theatre

        • Lifestyle
          • All
          • Fashion
          • Food & Drink
          • Health & Fitness
          Meat feast pizza

          Bella Italia launches new menu

          Ukrainian necklace

          Ukrainian Cultural Heritage: jewellery, accessories and some morale boosting art

          Leek and mushroom bake

          Leek and mushroom bake

          Byker children in community planting

          Byker Community Planting: growing food in a safe space in the city

          Ukrainian embroidery from Goodz

          Ukrainian Vyshyvanka: traditional embroidery

          Helen Hrynenko in traditional Ukrainian dress

          Ukrainian fashion: getting ready for Vyshyvanka Day

          Chana Bhuna

          Chana Bhuna

          dal

          Dal: delicious with yoghurt and chapatis

          chia seeds

          Chia egg cake

          Trending Tags

          • Business
            • All
            • Economy
            • Rural
            • Technology
            • Voluntary Sector
            Fishing protest

            Troubled waters: the forces behind the death of the Tees

            Renault Twizy

            Driving in style with my Renault Twizy

            office with computers

            Cyber-attacks, ransomware and the dark web

            man working from home in bed

            Is working from home good for business?

            Greggs coffee cup

            Tales from Greggs: celebrating a North East business

            Cold hands on radiator

            Fuel poverty is a serious problem for the North East

            Hannah Hauxwell in documentary Too long a Winter

            Hannah Hauxwell: How an isolated daleswoman became a national icon

            Message about Universal Basic Income

            Universal basic income: a moral necessity

            Job interview

            Hiring friends and family might actually be good for business says new research

            Trending Tags

            • Region
              • All
              • Co. Durham
              • North East
              • Northumberland
              • Teesside
              • Tyneside
              • Wearside
              Jack Charlton

              The Irish Ambassador honours Jack Charlton with a Presidential Award

              Silhouette of family

              Cost of living crisis: a fundamental rethink is needed to support families in the North East

              Civic Centre, Hartlepool

              Hartlepool Tories attend council meeting despite declaration of a boycott in the Cranney case

              Father and child in Newcastle

              Newcastle ranks among Europe’s top 20 cities for raising children

              Refugees welcome sign

              Tyneside groups pledge to carry on fight against government’s anti-refugee laws

              Jimmy Carter saying Howay the lads to the crowd with Jim Callaghan to his left and the lord mayor, Hugh White is just behind him.

              Time to remember the 45th anniversary of American President Jimmy Carter’s visit to Newcastle

              Open day with the fire service at South Shields

              A peek behind the fire curtain with TWFRS at South Shields open day

              Seaham Conservative Club

              ‘Death match’ wrestling at Seaham Conservative Club is under investigation

              Richard Holden

              Richard Holden, MP and Beergate: those who live by the smear fall by the same

              Trending Tags

              • Opinion
                Titanic coming out of Southampton

                The 110th anniversary of the Titanic’s departure

                There is an England

                There is an England

                Prime Minister Boris Johnson signs the Withdrawal Agreement with the European Union"

                The parody of disinformation: Boris Johnson on Ukraine and Brexit

                Boris Johnson’s comments on Ukraine and Brexit are an insult

                TV Agency staff jumping in the air

                The TV Agency celebrates 10th anniversary with global success

                North East of County Dublin

                North East of England and North East of County Dublin: Compare and contrast

                North Sea oil rig

                Copping out of COP: Ukraine, fossil fuels and nuclear fusion

                Placard with Boris Johnson as a clown

                Dictators, media and mobility: erosion of identity, sustenance and safety

                close up on a child's eye

                Racism and misogyny where there should have been safeguarding and security

              No Result
              View All Result
              North East Bylines
              No Result
              View All Result
              Home News Politics

              Keir Starmer and lockdown rules: what the law actually said about gatherings in April 2021

              Analysis of Starmer and 'beergate' by Alan Greene

              Alan Greene by Alan Greene
              12-05-2022 09:24
              in Politics
              Photo licensed by creative commons

              Photo licensed by creative commons

              Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
              ADVERTISEMENT

              Labour leader Keir Starmer insists that he did not break lockdown rules after being photographed drinking a beer and eating food during the local election campaign of April 2021. So confident is he that he didn’t, he has pledged to step down if he is fined by the police over the matter.

              The prime minister, Boris Johnson, has already been fined for breaking lockdown rules and is at the centre of ongoing police investigations into partying in Downing Street on numerous occasions in 2020 and 2021.

              The police have reopened a previously closed investigation into claims that Starmer broke lockdown rules when he and staff ate together at Durham Miners’ Hall in the run up to the May elections of 2021.

              But what were the rules that he allegedly breached and how are these different to the rules allegedly breached by the prime minister?

              What were the lockdown rules in April 2021?

              It is important to note that lockdown rules varied significantly at different points of the pandemic. So the rules in operation for, say, the Downing Street garden party of May 20 2020 were not the same as those in effect when Starmer and his staff gathered in Durham on April 30 2021.

              In the case of the Downing Street garden party of May 2020, the strictest rules were in place. People were not allowed to be outside of their homes without a “reasonable excuse”, with only essential work constituting a reasonable excuse.

              This very strict rule was not in effect on April 30 2021. Restrictions had been through numerous iterations by that point and had most recently been updated in England on April 12.

              The relevant rule at the time was the “prohibition on gatherings” in a “step 2 area” – the level of restrictions in operation in Durham on that date.

              There were different rules in effect for gatherings of fewer than 30 people and gatherings of more than 30 people. If fewer than 30 people were at the Durham Miners Hall that evening, Starmer may have a case to answer for “participating” in an unlawful gathering indoors. If there were more than 30 people present, he may also have a case to answer for “organising and facilitating” an unlawful gathering. This distinction was designed to deter people from organising gatherings such as raves and the like which involved large groups of people that could act as “super-spreader” events. You could therefore be guilty of an offence of organising a gathering of more than 30 people even if you yourself did not attend this event.

              But – crucially – whether there were fewer than 30 people present or more than 30 people present, gatherings were permissible if they fell into one of the stated exceptions in the regulations. And gatherings in a Step 2 area were allowed if they were “reasonably necessary for work purposes”.

              On this point, people may draw comparisons between the claims made by those defending any Downing Street events that took place around the same period, when strict – but not the strictest – rules were in place. But by the time of the event involving Starmer, there was also a further additional exception expressly provided for gatherings that are “reasonably necessary for the purposes of campaigning in an election or a referendum”.

              ‘Resuming work’: a red herring?

              Starmer claims that he ordered a takeaway for his team while they were working on the Labour local election campaign. Many people had travelled to Durham to work on this campaign and, as such, were not ordinarily resident there.

              The Labour leader argues that since all restaurants in the area were closed, the people at the hall had no choice but to eat and drink there. They were not in a position to return to their homes. Starmer insists that they then returned to work after eating – a claim that further underlines the link between the event and work.

              Even so, the fact that the attendees were not capable of returning home or eating in a restaurant may, nevertheless, make this a gathering that was “reasonably necessary for work purposes” or “reasonably necessary for the purposes of campaigning in an election or a referendum” even if they did not subsequently return to work. The argument could be made that all the people present were in Durham for work. They needed to eat and there was nowhere else for them to eat.

              What about the beer?

              On the other hand, Starmer’s critics point to the fact that he was photographed drinking a beer on the night in question as an indication that the event was not a work gathering or a gathering “reasonably necessary for the purposes of campaigning in an election”.

              There is nothing in the legislation on this point. Drinking alcohol would not be a deciding factor in determining whether the event was or was not a work gathering under the regulations.

              It may, however, be a factor to be taken into account by the police when assessing whether the gathering was “reasonably necessary”. The amount of alcohol consumed may also be a factor. The idea of what is “reasonably necessary” was specifically defined to be vague when the COVID legislation was devised because it would have been almost impossible to draw up of an exhaustive list of permitted and prohibited activities. As such, the law of the time did place a considerable amount of discretion in the hands of the police.

              The key question: was it ‘reasonably necessary’?

              So to sum up, if there were fewer than 30 people at the event, Starmer may have a case to answer for “participating” in an unlawful gathering. If there were more than 30 people, he may also have a case to answer for organising and facilitating” an unlawful gathering.

              Ultimately, however, the gathering may fall under the exemption for a gathering that was “reasonably necessary for work purposes” or “reasonably necessary for the purposes of campaigning in an election or a referendum”.The Conversation

              Alan Greene, Reader in Constitutional Law and Human Rights, University of Birmingham

              This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

              Richard Holden, MP and Beergate: those who live by the smear fall by the same
              ADVERTISEMENT
              Previous Post

              National Limerick Day

              Next Post

              Limerickish

              Alan Greene

              Alan Greene

              Related Posts

              Silhouette of family
              North East

              Cost of living crisis: a fundamental rethink is needed to support families in the North East

              by North East Bylines
              May 26, 2022
              American flag with gun, apple and pencils
              Poetry

              A star spangled lullaby

              by Harry Gallagher
              May 26, 2022
              Map showing British Empire in 1886
              Politics

              Three imperial policies that still influence life in Britain today

              by Hunter Harris
              May 26, 2022
              Anna Bird CEO EMUK
              Politics

              European Movement describes failures of leadership and a toxic culture at the centre of Number 10

              by Yvonne Wancke
              May 25, 2022
              Civic Centre, Hartlepool
              Politics

              Hartlepool Tories attend council meeting despite declaration of a boycott in the Cranney case

              by Julia Mazza
              May 25, 2022
              Next Post
              Limerick

              Limerickish

              Want to support us?

              Can you help North East Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

              DONATE

              Sign up to our newsletter

              If you would like to receive the North East Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

              NEWSLETTER

              LATEST

              Jack Charlton

              The Irish Ambassador honours Jack Charlton with a Presidential Award

              May 28, 2022
              A way home promo photo

              A Way Home: the true story of Durham’s category ‘D’ villages brought to life in new play

              May 27, 2022
              "Molly Scott Cato in Bristol" by Bristol Green Party is marked with CC0 1.0.

              Government loses sight of climate crisis as energy windfall tax encourages rise in fossil fuel investment

              May 27, 2022
              Silhouette of family

              Cost of living crisis: a fundamental rethink is needed to support families in the North East

              May 26, 2022
              American flag with gun, apple and pencils

              A star spangled lullaby

              May 26, 2022
              Map showing British Empire in 1886

              Three imperial policies that still influence life in Britain today

              May 26, 2022

              MOST READ

              Jack Charlton

              The Irish Ambassador honours Jack Charlton with a Presidential Award

              May 28, 2022
              A way home promo photo

              A Way Home: the true story of Durham’s category ‘D’ villages brought to life in new play

              May 27, 2022
              "Molly Scott Cato in Bristol" by Bristol Green Party is marked with CC0 1.0.

              Government loses sight of climate crisis as energy windfall tax encourages rise in fossil fuel investment

              May 27, 2022
              Silhouette of family

              Cost of living crisis: a fundamental rethink is needed to support families in the North East

              May 26, 2022

              BROWSE BY TAGS

              Brexit Business Co. Durham Culture democracy Economy Education Environment Food & Drink Health & Care Home Affairs Lifestyle Local Lockdown Northumberland Peace Performance Politics Science Social Media Teesside TV & Radio Tyneside Ukraine Wearside

              North East Bylines is a regional online newspaper that supports citizen journalism. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in the North East and beyond.

              Learn more about us

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Contact
              • About
              • Letters
              • Donate
              • Privacy
              • Bylines network
              • Shop

              © 2022 North East Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Home
              • News
                • Brexit
                • Education
                • Environment
                • UK News
                • Transport
                • World News
              • Politics
              • Opinion
              • Lifestyle
                • Culture
                • Music
                • Poetry
              • Business
                • Economy
                • Technology
                • Trade
              • Donate
              • Newsletter sign up
              • Boriiis Cartoons
              • Authors

              © 2022 North East Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              Welcome Back!

              Login to your account below

              Forgotten Password?

              Retrieve your password

              Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

              Log In