• Contact
  • About
  • ISSN 3049-9763
  • Authors and editors
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
North East Bylines
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News
  • Culture
  • Lifestyle
  • Business
  • Region
  • Opinion
AUDIO
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Culture
  • Lifestyle
  • Business
  • Region
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
North East Bylines
Home News Environment

Silence of the seals

The majority of harbour seal pups at the Tees Estuary are dying, year on year. Why you aren’t being told what’s going on…

Milo Brett by Milo Brett
21-10-2026 10:00
in Environment, Teesside
Reading Time: 12 mins read
A A
The Tees harbour seal pups are born on the mud-flats of Seal Sands and Greatham Creek

The Tees harbour seal pups are born on the mud-flats of Seal Sands and Greatham CreekThe Tees harbour seal pups are born on the mud-flats of Seal Sands and Greatham Creek, Tara Seals Research

Share on Bluesky

Teesside seal reporting 1989-2022 

The Tees harbour seal colony was first seriously studied back in 1989 by David Bellamy Associates (DBA) together with Teesside Development Corporation (TDC). Through combined efforts, they set up a comprehensive seal monitoring programme at Seal Sands.  The initial observations made for bleak reading – only a single pup was born every other year and died soon after birth. They were very underweight with high levels of the toxic forever chemicals, polychlorinated biphenyls or ‘PCBs’, present in their bodies. However, the birth rate has since recovered, with records showing more than 20 pups born each year on the mud-flats of Seal Sands and Greatham Creek.

You might then assume that the harbour seal colony is now stable and thriving, and that this represents a conservation success. Herein lies the illusion.

The Tees harbour seal pups are born on the mud-flats of Seal Sands and Greatham Creek
The Tees harbour seal pups are born on the mud-flats of Seal Sands and Greatham Creek, Tara Seals Research

The Industry Nature Conservation Association (INCA) has been monitoring the colony since 1994. Their annual reports use a very simplified version of the original DBA monitoring system which lacks photographic verification, behaviour observations and contaminant analyses. Crucially these reports have not properly addressed seal mortality or its potential causes. A backwards step from the initial thoroughness introduced by DBA. 

In 2022 the original research personnel from DBA, now of Tara Seal Research (TSR), received a distressed call for help from a concerned individual saying that the Tees seal pups were stranding, emaciated and dying before they were even two months old. Due to this tragic situation TSR began a preliminary investigative study (Tees Estuary Seal Study, or TESS) with assistance from local volunteers. The results were as shocking as they had been back in the early 90s. Mostof the harbour seal pups that were born on Teesside were dying within weeks of leaving their mothers. 

The seal pups were succumbing to what has become known as “mouth rot” — a rapidly progressing, non-communicable, necrotising condition that destroys tissue around the mouth and jaw. Pups first become lethargic and then develop visible swelling around the chin and muzzle.

A pup struggling to reunite with its mother off-shore and collapsing with exhaustion., Tara Seals Research
A pup struggling to reunite with its mother off-shore and collapsing with exhaustion., Tara Seals Research
A pup struggling to reunite with its mother off-shore and collapsing with exhaustion., Tara Seals Research
A pup struggling to reunite with its mother off-shore and collapsing with exhaustion., Tara Seals Research

Tara Seal Research and their findings

TSR has been studying and analysing the present mouth-rot epidemic since 2024. The team has since focused on pursuing theories put forward by DBA all those years ago – high PCB levels found in the tissues of dead or euthanised pups. Numerous toxicological and physiological studies over the past 30 years have now established that seal pups ingest PCBs from their mother’s milk, which has bioaccumulated in them from contaminated fish. The dioxin-like PCBs render the pups underweight through reduced glucose uptake and immune-suppressed via thyroid hormone dysfunction – the most likely contributor to the condition in which stranded Tees pups are found. 

TESS field observations since 2024 have suggested a further environmental issue leading to the mouth rot:

The physical weakness and immune suppression arising from high PCB levels, renders young pups particularly vulnerable to the overgrowth of normally occurring oral bacteria, as well as, possible pathogenic bacteria in the mud-flats of Seal Sands where they are suckling. 

Thus, the TSR working hypothesis is that: 

As a pup suckles, they are ingesting PCBs from their mother’s milk while simultaneously ingesting bacterial contaminants present in the mud that coats their mother’s belly and nipples. At the age of 4-5 weeks the pups leave the estuary having been weaned. Within days or weeks, these pups re-appear stranded along the coastline in a moribund condition and very underweight. This immunosuppressed condition caused by the PCBs results in the bacterial overload, in turn, developing into necrotising mouth rot. 

Blubber and tissue samples analysed by TSR to date are consistent with this working hypothesis. In 2025, six of eight euthanised pups investigated by TSR had growths of E. coli in their mouths, indicative of sewage pollution. Northumbrian Water has since confirmed sewage spills at Seal Sands and Greatham Creek during the 2024 and 2025 pupping season.

Mother’s belly covered in potentially contaminated mud as its pup suckles, Tara Seals Research
Mother’s belly covered in potentially contaminated mud as its pup suckles, Tara Seals Research

The counter narrative

The Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (DEFRA) has, however, been promoting an altogether different narrative. The Government department has been controlling and funding studies on the seal pup deaths, UK wide. In conjunction with Teesside University (TU) and British Divers Marine Life Rescue (BDMLR) they have put forward a “viral” theory of a ‘new calicivirus’, claiming this is the underlying cause of the mouth-rot. 

But neither the context nor the epidemiology of the mouth-rot are consistent with an infectious virus. Mouth-rot is affecting newborn seal pups year on year and not their mothers or other seals in the colony. 

Although the virus theory is not supported by a published scientific paper, DEFRA has recently granted Teesside University Enterprise and Innovation (TUEI) £159,785.51 to develop a lateral flow viral test for stranded seal pups. 

The focus on a viral cause appears to have the effect of understating or even dismissing any form of environmental contamination as a potential contributor to the seal pups’ condition. In their response, DEFRA did not acknowledge the downplaying of environmental pollution.

Inconsistencies and concerns over stranded pup care

Last year a resident Hartlepool vet issued a public statement calling for a locally-based seal  hospital where pups could be treated and restored to health instead of being euthanised. The vet’s call was followed up again by the BBC this year. TSR has supported this appeal since 2024, emphasising that even a temporary facility would make a difference with current recovery rate allowing for immediate, intensive care and avoiding needless lengthy transportation.

An official application for this facility was presented to Northumbrian Water (NWL) earlier this year but refused on the grounds that Teesmouth Seal Conservation Trust (TSCT – now embodied in Teesside Environmental Trust (TET) and cross-organisational personal connection with BDMLR) were already caring for stranded seal pups during the 2026 breeding season. 

In a statement made to NWL, TSCT said that “in partnership with Natural England, we will have emergency veterinary care services available this summer for pups who have been triaged by the BDMLR network as in need of attention or euthanasia”.

Since 2023, similar assurances have been maintained, that the former South Gare lifeboat station would be used by TSCT as a pup rehabilitation centre. But four years on, no treatment is taking place here and the facility is still non-functional. TSCT were approached for a statement on this but did not answer.

Earlier in the 2026 season, a verbal statement from TSCT/TET indicated that pups coming to them would have to be euthanised owing to the absence of a local rehabilitation facility. They have confirmed that this has, more often than not, been the case for rescued pups suffering from mouth rot. 

What is happening in the absence of immediate treatment? 

The BDMLR operate across the UK coastline and have positioned themselves as the exclusive first response unit for seal strandings in the North East of England. Seal pups in their possession are under their control alone, despite their head office being located in East Sussex. This stranglehold is creating a situation where TSR or others are being barred from obtaining any pertinent information relating to pups they have been monitoring since birth. 

Neither BDMLR nor TSCT are able to provide accessible records of stranding information. BDMLR were asked about their lack of coordination with TSR over stranding records, to which they provided a link for their webpage containing “stranding information”. The only comprehensive information on this page pertains to the total number of stranded pups they have collected per county. Their precise location, condition and outcome is not publicly disclosed. These details are essential to independent scientists seeking to gain a greater understanding of the disease that is systematically destroying every annual cohort of harbour seal pups on the Tees.

Ultimately, the consequences of not co-operating with external experts and working without transparency will hinder any chance the Tees seal population have to survive.

Is treatment even possible?

During the summer of 2025 the TSR team examined and took samples from five pups that had been taken by BDMLR and euthanised. Examination of the pups and their mouths indicated that all five appeared to be in reasonable condition and at a relatively early stage of mouth rot. They could, therefore, have received treatment and not been prematurely – in TSR’s view – euthanised. BDMLR did not respond to this in a request for comment.

To put this into stark contrast, at seal pup rehabilitation centres away from Teesside, TSR has observed that even pups with relatively advanced mouth rot and deep ulceration have been given care, medication and a chance to live.

The comparison inevitably raises a difficult question; if humanitarian treatment and care is possible elsewhere, why were TSR prevented from carrying it out on Teesside during the summer of 2026?

The answer may boil down to a network of organisations on Teesside, ostensibly involved with the conservation of the Tees harbour seal colony, seal pup rescue and care. These organisations have extensive overlapping relationships through funding arrangements, partnerships and shared personnel.

”Oh what a tangled web…”: the network of organisations controlling the conservation of the Teesside seal colony.
”Oh what a tangled web…”: the network of organisations controlling the conservation of the Teesside seal colony.

This network has created what appears to be a ‘closed shop’ in which independent scientific analysis of mouth rot and assistance in seal rehabilitation are excluded and the sharing of resources and expertise are denied. 

This cannot be the right way forward. A lack of openness not only prevents independent bodies from providing aid but also enables potential misrepresentations of the shockingly high annual mortality rate of Tees pups or that everything possible is being done to care for individual pups.

DEFRA has insisted that they are working “closely with […] wildlife experts”, but this does not seem to include TSR who have decades worth of expertise and published studies on seal biology.

Enough politics. The seals need help now.   

The situation is critical. Urgent action must be taken to ensure that the coming years see a decline in the number of dying pups and an increase in success stories of collaborative rehabilitation efforts and research into the causes of mouth rot. What needs to change? 

• Teesside urgently needs a dedicated intensive care facility where stranded pups can receive immediate veterinary treatment and humanitarian care, with supervision by a qualified independent seal biologist.

• The whereabouts and condition of pups retrieved from coastal stranding needs to be made accessible to research groups, veterinarians and volunteers. 

• Complete and accurate records of every individual pup stranding in the North east region should be shared openly in real time and samples made available to independent research biologists.

• Genuine and demonstrable collaboration is essential amongst and between volunteers, independent scientists, veterinarians and statutory agencies.

Deeper questions will still remain over the role of decades of industrial contamination. Until these questions are openly addressed, the seals and their pups will remain the victims of a much larger environmental failure. 

Put simply, a sea change is needed from the regional organisations overseeing the current crisis.The recovery of the Teesside seal population is dependent on transparency, accountability and the willingness to confront uncomfortable truths over sewage pollution and PCB origins. 

The harbour seals of the Tees have long been celebrated as the jewel in the crown of the estuary’s wildlife and it remains increasingly uncertain whether there will be any future generations left of Tees harbour seal pups.

What happens when the media itself becomes part of the problem? Who holds it to account? 14 years after the Leveson Inquiry reported its findings, has anything really changed? And how can we build something better?

Join Bylines Network on Wednesday 21 October, for a vital conversation about the media Britain needs — and what it will take to get there.

The event will conclude with a live audience Q&A.

BOOK NOW
Previous Post

Building a coalfield commonwealth: Redhills Assembly Day Two

Next Post

Durham: Deputy leader Darren Grimes under fire after undercover investigation

Milo Brett

Milo Brett

Related Posts

white ribbon day
Community

Domestic violence in the spotlight at white ribbon event

by North East Bylines
9 November 2026
Crown Pub, Middlesbrough
Opinion

King Ben Houchen is losing his Crown. And judging by Wednesday’s performance, he’s losing the plot as well (Part Two – Meeting your adoring public)

by Ray Casey
8 November 2026
Crown Pub, Middlesbrough
Opinion

King Ben Houchen is losing his Crown. And judging by Wednesday’s performance, he’s losing the plot as well (Part One – Ham Radio)

by Ray Casey
7 November 2026
Intensive discussions
Environment

What’s in the air? And am I a Smoggie? Two key questions for Teessiders

by Ray Casey
4 November 2026 - Updated on 5 November 2026
An aerial picture of the Hauxley natural reserve
Environment

Using technology to help people connect with wildlife

by Peter Sagar
4 November 2026
Next Post
Reform UK logo

Durham: Deputy leader Darren Grimes under fire after undercover investigation

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

BROWSE BY TAGS

#BenHouchen Ben Houchen Business Co. Durham community Culture Darlington Durham Economy Education entertainment Environment Equality Finance Funding Gateshead Hartlepool Health History Housing Human Rights Investment Local Lockdown Middlesbrough Newcastle North East Northumberland Online safety opinion Peace Politics Redcar STDC Stockton Sunderland Technology Teesside Teesworks Transport TVCA Tyneside Ukraine Wearside Which?

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in the North East and beyond.

North East Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Networks Limited which is separate to, but allied with, Byline Times.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Authors and editors
  • Complaints
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Letters
  • Privacy
  • Network Map
  • Network RSS Feeds
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Download the Bylines Network App

© 2020-2026 North East Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9763

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • UK News
    • Transport
    • World News
  • Opinion
  • Lifestyle
    • Culture
    • Music
    • Poetry
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Technology
    • Trade
  • Audio
  • Authors and editors

Newsletter sign up

CROWDFUNDER

© 2020-2026 North East Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9763