• Contact
  • About
  • ISSN 3049-9763
  • Authors and editors
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
North East Bylines
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News
  • Culture
  • Lifestyle
  • Business
  • Region
  • Opinion
AUDIO
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Culture
  • Lifestyle
  • Business
  • Region
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
North East Bylines
Home News Politics

Tougher scrutiny on the way for councils and combined authorities

Gove announces new Local Government Office, OfLog in long overdue move

Peter Morris by Peter Morris
28-01-2023 13:24 - Updated on 19-03-2023 20:20
in Politics
Reading Time: 7 mins read
A A
Michael Gove

Photo credit: Jakub Junek/Shutterstock.com

Share on Bluesky

Tougher scrutiny of the performance of the leaders of local authorities, the mayors of combined authorities and the cabinet members of both is on the way. A new Office for Local Government (OfLog) will supplement or replace the work of existing overview and scrutiny committees (OSCs) of backbenchers; details are awaited from the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities (DLUHC).

The announcement by Levelling Up Secretary Michael Gove in a little-reported section of his speech to the Convention of the North this week, is long overdue.

Meanwhile, the Shadow Levelling Up Secretary, Lisa Nandy, has told the Local Government Chronicle that a Labour government would introduce local versions of parliament’s Public Accounts Committee (PAC) in devolved areas to “bake in” accountability.

The PAC, according to its website:

“examines the value for money of government projects, programmes and service delivery. Drawing on the work of the National Audit Office (NAO), the committee holds government officials to account for the economy, efficiency and effectiveness of public spending.”

Gove told the Convention of the North that a former chair of the NAO, Amyas Morse (Lord Morse), had agreed to chair the new OfLog and that the DLUHC would launch a competition to find a chief executive to lead the organisation in the days ahead. He said:

“[B]ecause accountability is key to effective delivery we will also improve the knowledge all voters have about the performance of all local leaders. Our new Office for Local Government will produce detailed and precise comparison of delivery across local authorities and mayoral combined authorities.

“Value for money and effectiveness of service will be measured more effectively than ever before, monitored and analysed so we can learn from the best and support others to improve…

“I am confident it will be another step in enhancing the role local leaders play in our political lives and in delivering economic growth. The greater scrutiny will not only further sharpen efficiency and spread learning. It will, I know, show how successful devolution is, can and will be in the future.”

Essential

According to the Local Government Association:

“Scrutiny is an essential part of ensuring that local government remains transparent, accountable and open, resulting in improved public policies and services.”

Yet research by this author and others has found that the present OSC system is far less robust at holding mayors and leading councillors to account than it should be due to a combination of factors including party loyalty, a tradition of privacy and absenteeism from key meetings.

The OSC system came into existence under the Local Government Act 2000, which also introduced a separation between mayors and council leaders and their cabinets – the executive – on one hand and backbench councillors, whose main task is overview and scrutiny, on the other.

As long ago as 2004 Professor Colin Copus found that once a majority party group has elected a leader and s/he has selected cabinet members from within the group there is a reluctance to criticise robustly in the OSC, which meets in public, and a preference for dealing with problems in the privacy of party groups:

“There is a tendency emerging for majority group councillors to see their role as defending the executive from being badly mauled by overview and scrutiny or being subject to criticism and challenge by councillors from other parties,” writes Copus.

“Moreover, some majority groups have already shown themselves unwilling to scrutinise in public an executive that they themselves put into place and whose political policies they support. Indeed, some councillors see loyalty to the executive as inextricably tied up with party and group loyalty and set out to positively protect the executive from challenge by OSC.”

Inquorate meetings

The Centre for Governance and Scrutiny (CfGS) has found another problem affecting combined authorities (CAs) in particular: inquorate meetings.

Quoracy requirements for CAs, it points out, are set out in legislation and the bar is set high for the good reason that credibility and legitimacy will be damaged if many constituent councils are effectively unrepresented.

The large geographies of some CAs may make attendance at meetings difficult, while some councillors may not see the value in CA scrutiny and could be voting with their feet.

“Evidence varies here,” says the CfGS. “Inevitably some members are more engaged than others. At this stage there is no evidence to support a widespread disillusionment with and disengagement from CA scrutiny – CA scrutiny is, in many areas, delivering high quality work.”

There is another, more worrying reason for inquorate scrutiny meetings, according to the CfGS:

“There is the risk that the quoracy regime can be used cynically by political parties – by informally withdrawing members from the committee to limit discussion on a given matter. Such allegations have been made – and are difficult to either prove or disprove. The quoracy requirements can be misused like this, of course, but this does not seem to be a widespread issue.”

For whatever reasons, inquorate meetings have been found to be a problem in some places. The CfGS cites Cambridgeshire & Peterborough as the most high-profile example, but this author has also found it in the North East.

Inquoracy was at its most serious at the North East Local Enterprise Partnership (NELEP) between 2017 and 2019. While NELEP is a private sector-led organisation and not subject to the same scrutiny arrangements as CAs, it does have council leaders on its board and it is their job to act as “one part of the LEP’s democratic accountability’” according to the then Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG).

Yet between two quorate meetings in May 2017 and January 2019 NELEP held nine consecutive inquorate meetings, and in seven of those cases it was the absence of council leaders that caused the problem.

So seriously did the government take the situation that inquorate meetings were the main governance issue raised when NELEP underwent its annual appraisal in January 2019 at a meeting attended by a senior civil servant and NELEP leaders. They assured the MHCLG that the matter was being raised with board members and constituent local authorities and would also be raised at the next board away day.

Observers

Matters have improved since then, but meetings are still intermittently either inquorate or quorate only because of advice by the chief executive that councillors present as observers can be counted towards the required number.

The North of Tyne Combined Authority (NTCA) has an almost unblemished record over the past three years, with only one inquorate meeting in February 2022, and the North East Combined Authority (NECA) has improved since a series of inquorate meetings in 2017-18.

The problem noted by Copus of backbenchers on OSCs being reluctant to criticise their executive party colleagues can also be found in the North East. The relationship can appear cosy rather than business-like. The minutes of NECA’s OSC record that on one occasion the committee was of the view that “there should be more publicity generally of the positive things that were happening within NECA.”

A more significant instance occurred when Tees Valley CA’s OSC attempted, and failed, to challenge Mayor Ben Houchen’s purchase of Teesside Airport, something which all five members of his cabinet at the time opposed.

“I don’t think we did enough” one OSC member said ruefully afterwards, and at an (inquorate) meeting the chair remarked that the committee must play a significant role in future overview and scrutiny of the airport. It was stressed, the meeting notes record, that serious debate was needed about the role of O&S and that an arrangement needed to be in place to allow effective and timely scrutiny.

That is perhaps what Gove’s new OfLog under the experienced Lord Morse, or Nandy’s local public accounts committees, will provide. It is needed.

Previous Post

Bay Tales: crime fiction festival returns to Whitley Bay

Next Post

Master Chef of Great Britain joins Leila Lily’s

Peter Morris

Peter Morris

I am a semi-retired journalist with experience in North East newspapers dating back to 1964. I have worked on Tyneside, Wearside and Teesside, specialising in regional politics and local government before moving into newsdesk management. I have also worked in media relations for the government. Since retiring I have studied at university and gained a PhD in economic geography.

Related Posts

war memorial
Health

Welfare and warfare

by Michal Chantkowski
16 November 2026
Ben Houchen
Politics

Tees Valley Mayor rejects proposed salary increase

by Daniel Hodgson
15 November 2026
Mary Bythell - taking her fight against the far-right to rural Northumberland
Northumberland

The fight against the far right goes on

by Andy Cooper
15 November 2026
Typewriter with paper reading Job applications
Equality

One in five young people in the North East has gone missing. The jobs guarantee won’t find them

by Greng Hassan
15 November 2026
People standing holding hands
Community

Standing Together against violence in the West Bank

by Peter Sagar
14 November 2026
Next Post
Jim Hall

Master Chef of Great Britain joins Leila Lily’s

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

BROWSE BY TAGS

#BenHouchen Ben Houchen Business Co. Durham community Culture Darlington Durham Economy Education entertainment Environment Equality Finance Funding Gateshead Hartlepool Health History Housing Human Rights Investment Local Lockdown Middlesbrough Newcastle North East Northumberland Online safety opinion Peace Politics Redcar STDC Stockton Sunderland Technology Teesside Teesworks Transport TVCA Tyneside Ukraine Wearside Which?

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in the North East and beyond.

North East Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Networks Limited which is separate to, but allied with, Byline Times.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Authors and editors
  • Complaints
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Letters
  • Privacy
  • Network Map
  • Network RSS Feeds
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Download the Bylines Network App

© 2020-2026 North East Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9763

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • UK News
    • Transport
    • World News
  • Opinion
  • Lifestyle
    • Culture
    • Music
    • Poetry
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Technology
    • Trade
  • Audio
  • Authors and editors

Newsletter sign up

CROWDFUNDER

© 2020-2026 North East Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9763