• Contact
  • About
  • ISSN 3049-9763
  • Authors and editors
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
North East Bylines
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News
  • Culture
  • Lifestyle
  • Business
  • Region
  • Opinion
AUDIO
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Culture
  • Lifestyle
  • Business
  • Region
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
North East Bylines
Home News Opinion

Oath of allegiance: demanding loyalty is divisive

"Swearing to (not at) the crown or otherwise just isn’t something most Brits normally do..."

Robin Tudge by Robin Tudge
04-05-2023 11:36
in Opinion, UK News
Reading Time: 8 mins read
A A
King Edwards Crown to be used by King Charles III for his Coronation sits on a purple pillow with a purple background.

King Edwards Crown to be used by King Charles III for his Coronation Photo credit: Traceyaphotos2/Shutterstock.com

Share on Bluesky

This Saturday, for the coronation, we’ve been ‘invited’ to take the oath of allegiance to the King. I won’t be taking it, I’m not massively anti-monarchy but I just don’t understand the whole thing of royalty anymore, and if the point of an oath of allegiance is to unify us around the crown, it’ll prove immediately, obviously divisive between those doing it and those not, be folk doing it or denouncing it online, on the bus, or wherever – knowing how this government thrives on division, that’s probably half the point.

Will there be titters and fisticuffs, stand up rows? Or maybe more sinister outcomes, the oath-takers gaining favour while the deniers fall foul, as this ‘invitation’ proves to be posh parlance for ‘do as you are told’ and the oath indicates people’s propensity to obey as well as be loyal.

Brits swearing oaths to the king – its history touches on the real divisions beneath the United Kingdom, steeped in competing nationalities, loyalties to the Crown or the King of Kings (and strains thereof). Henry VIII’s ecumenical Engxit (with its concomitant cultural destruction, mass persecutions and centuries of division, pogroms and sectarian Hell, the Reformation itself proving so divisive his own daughter Mary sought to undo it, before her sister Elizabeth re-established it … ) to divorce England from the Vatican also required all priestly types swear loyalty to Him and not the Pope.

As Elizabeth I also laid down the Royal Navy, their officers don’t have to swear allegiance as it’s implicit by the navy’s very existence, whereas the other armed services, as parliament’s creation, must prove their allegiance to the crown. As do MPs themselves, forfeiting their seats and salaries “as if they were dead” if they don’t, as also must the leaders and representatives in Scotland and Wales’ devolved parliaments – presumably to prevent their intentions straying too far – but not in Stormont, where loyalties as per ‘nationalist’, ‘unionist’, or ‘other’ are logged in something of a doomsome ledger. 

Members of the judiciary swear allegiance to the king, his heirs and successors, while English police only swear allegiance to the king – as the RUC used to, but its successor does not – and Scottish police never swore for no-one. (Makes things complicated for the Oaths of Allegiance online shop). Many cases of “don’t ask, cos you won’t like the answer.”

Various services and institutions besides needing or not to swear, swearing to (not at) the crown or otherwise just isn’t something most Brits normally do – and even immigrants wanting to become Brits, assuming they’ve passed a British citizen quiz most Brits would fail, don’t have to. Instead at their citizenship ceremonies they can take the Oath of Allegiance (swearing by God fealty to the King) – or, the Affirmation (swearing fealty to the King, but not by God) – or, the Pledge (just be lawful and respectful, forget the king or God).

I’d imagine Twitter would cash in with something like red ticks for oath takers’ profiles, that Jacob Rees-Mogg or Richard Tice would weaponise as proof they’re the kind of worthy Brit “believers” who can unquestioningly follow orders (something of the Koresh about Tice, with his Sunday Sermon TV show, and how he described Farage’s plane crash survival in holy miracle terms). All a bit fascist but like most things with these righties in this country their evil would be limited by the sh***iness of its execution. Elsewhere though, oath-taking has gone seriously pear-shaped.

Oath Keepers

In the US the Oath Keepers, the very well tooled up paramilitary organisation – as in has thousands of current and former military and security personnel in its ranks – in the vanguard of the assault on the Capitol on 6 January, 2021, at the suggestion if not outright order of Donald Trump, to violently overthrow the wholly legitimate election of Joe Biden. In the name of defending the Constitution they sought to ransack the most revered edifice and process of its democracy.

Some of them and their co-patriots would have been of the generation that undertook the Land of the Free’s unique school ritual, standing hand-on-heart and reciting the Pledge of Allegiance (still seen at big ball games).

Classically American, the pledge came about as a mix of patriotism and profit. As the Conversation tells it, Civil War veterans wanted to prevent any future conflict by instilling in the young a sense of spiritual ardour for the Stars and Stripes (NOT the Confederate flag) on a parr with the Israelites’ reverence for the Ark of the Covenant. Then in 1892 the pledge and its recitation were added as a marketing gimmick to sell more flags and with millions of schoolchildren flash-mobbing it in class, the pledge became a patriotic smash hit, and over the years became mandated by state after state until by the 1930s it was nationwide.

Jehovah’s Witnesses

Except the Jehovah’s Witnesses couldn’t let their children do it, their covenant with God prohibiting the veneration of a bit of cloth. So it went to court, and in 1935 the Supreme Court chose the need for national unity over the Witnesses’ First Amendment rights – all the kids would pledge, no exceptions. The flipside for the Witnesses was they were now framed as disloyal Americans, and would suffer real violence to their persons, their businesses, and homes, for years.

The Supreme Court overturned this compulsion in 1943, possibly juxtaposing this violence against the far horizon over Europe where proving loyalty was proving murderous to the tune of tens of millions under the Nazis. And again, as the United States Holocaust Museum notes, it was the Jehovah’s Witnesses again who copped it, heroically standing by their beliefs that prohibited swearing loyalty to any earthly government, including the Nazis, or joining the military, for which they were tried, imprisoned and killed.

The Nazis

And yet, the Nazis themselves only got as far as they did by tweaking the military’s oath of allegiance. Before bringing on the entirety of humanity across the planet onto their own heads, initially the greatest threat to the Nazis actually stemmed from the aristocrat officers in the German military, who despised this upstart Austrian, and its millions of troops being sworn to defend the very state and constitution the Nazis were bent on burning.

Hence in 1934 the ranks were bade to swear an oath of allegiance to the Fuhrer over that for the constitution and the state – a subtle sleight of words that harnessed the world’s most powerful war machine to the ambitions of an astoundingly evil man, even to the point of their own country’s destruction. Ironically, the journey for some of the officers involved in the July 1944 bomb plot began with the disquiet of making this oath to Hitler – self-fulfilling his suspicions – yet, for many, that same oath stayed their hand (read Joachim Fest’s Plotting Hitler’s Death), and for far too many soldiers covered the committing of barbarities across a continent, for which they could claim, “we are only following orders”.

And it was that ‘only following orders’ bit that the Oath Keepers were set up in the noughties to hold off, should the Constitution be imperiled by someone like “Hitlery” Clinton, as its founder wrote in NOT Just Following Orders, a Hitlery totalitarian state “cannot happen here if the majority of police and soldiers obey their oaths to defend the Constitution and refuse to enforce the unconstitutional edicts of the ‘leader’.” Great ambition, kind of gone rogue though.

Charles III isn’t Hitler, and Britain First and the Khmer Blukips in and hanging around government don’t have the Keepers’ kind of firepower. But when people in privilege and power demand loyalty it’s usually because they’re feeling insecure about something, and that only ever ends in violence.

Previous Post

Community Payback Project: ‘Justice Seen, Justice Done’ in Kenton

Next Post

Coastline Runner: collecting shoreline plastic

Robin Tudge

Robin Tudge

Robin Tudge is a writer, activist, and editor, and his debut novel Mr Whippy Goes to Schaumberg is available on Amazon. He's also an actor, and has been an EMT for London Ambulance Service and a tour guide in North Korea, but has settled for living in Edinburgh, itinerantly attending his blog.

Related Posts

Misinformation
Opinion

Before we accuse AI of spreading nonsense, perhaps we should examine our own

by Ray Lowry
14 November 2026
Photo by Sasun Bughdaryan on Unsplash
North East

Young people and work: the North East can turn what we know into opportunity

by Nick Kemp
13 November 2026
Crown Pub, Middlesbrough
Opinion

King Ben Houchen is losing his Crown. And judging by Wednesday’s performance, he’s losing the plot as well (Part Two – Meeting your adoring public)

by Ray Casey
8 November 2026
Crown Pub, Middlesbrough
Opinion

King Ben Houchen is losing his Crown. And judging by Wednesday’s performance, he’s losing the plot as well (Part One – Ham Radio)

by Ray Casey
7 November 2026
Zack Polanski. Picture by Rob Browne
Opinion

When the wealthy politicians fear, out come the smears

by James Jobson
6 November 2026
Next Post
Luke running in North Shields (Long Sands Beach) this morning – 4th May

Coastline Runner: collecting shoreline plastic

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

BROWSE BY TAGS

#BenHouchen Ben Houchen Business Co. Durham community Culture Darlington Durham Economy Education entertainment Environment Equality Finance Funding Gateshead Hartlepool Health History Housing Human Rights Investment Local Lockdown Middlesbrough Newcastle North East Northumberland Online safety opinion Peace Politics Redcar STDC Stockton Sunderland Technology Teesside Teesworks Transport TVCA Tyneside Ukraine Wearside Which?

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in the North East and beyond.

North East Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Networks Limited which is separate to, but allied with, Byline Times.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Authors and editors
  • Complaints
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Letters
  • Privacy
  • Network Map
  • Network RSS Feeds
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Download the Bylines Network App

© 2020-2026 North East Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9763

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • UK News
    • Transport
    • World News
  • Opinion
  • Lifestyle
    • Culture
    • Music
    • Poetry
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Technology
    • Trade
  • Audio
  • Authors and editors

Newsletter sign up

CROWDFUNDER

© 2020-2026 North East Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9763