Middlesbrough is the most challenging place in England to be a child, and Sunderland is the ninth most challenging. North Tyneside on the other hand is the 14th least challenging out of 153 top-tier local authority districts.
“Some of the things I have seen and heard recently have utterly disgusted me,” writes the Children’s Commissioner, Dame Rachel de Souza, in a covering document to her new report “The Childhood Lottery” published on 19 October.
“Two weeks ago, based on some of the data in this report, I visited Middlesbrough, to hear from children in one of the most difficult places to be a child.”
Her immediately following sentences, though not explicitly referring to the Teesside town, certainly could be: “I have seen what it looks like for children to grow up in a difficult place.
“I have listened to a 14-year old girl tell me about the crime statistics in her local area. Children should not have to know those statistics. Their parents should not have to talk about them over dinner to explain why children cannot play outside. Schools should not have administrative staff dealing with drug overdoses and racist thugs. Nowhere in England should ‘a chase from the police’ be a primary source of entertainment.”
Mayor hits back
The Mayor of Middlesbrough, Chris Cooke, reacted angrily: “This is a label our children don’t deserve and I’m angry for that reason,” he said. “I’m also angry for the thousands of people in our town who put their heart and soul into giving our young people the best chance in life. They will feel frustrated that we have another set of headlines that can damage hope and limit ambition.
“I’m determined to fight for our children and young people so that labels like this don’t become self-fulfilling. We can’t allow them to give up on whatever dreams they have in life.
“Many of the findings in this research are sadly nothing new – they’re linked to multi-generational social problems, inequalities in funding and national policies going back decades. I desperately hope this report leads to proper and immediate action.”
Measuring the hardship
Dame Rachel has compiled 162 metrics, many of which are outside local authority control and come under the NHS or police, for example. The data comes from the Children’s Commissioner’s own sources and analysis, the Department for Education and ten other public bodies. Sunderland City Council pointed out that its Children’ Services were rated outstanding in the last Ofsted inspection.
Dame Rachel writes: “[W]hat stands out is not merely the differences, but how much work there is to do to deliver a happy, healthy childhood in every postcode.
Difficult decision to name names
I have made the difficult decision to highlight the 20 places where it is hardest to grow up. I want to be clear that this is not a review of the local authority, this is an assessment based on a wide range of measures looking at the challenges faced, the full range of services available and the outcomes we see.
“We cannot shy away, though, from the fact that poor education outcomes, long health waiting lists or simply feeling unsafe converge in particular places. It is also no coincidence that as Children’s Commissioner I have already visited many of them.
“I hope by presenting the data in this new way we can shine a light on the local, regional and national action needed to improve children’s lives in these areas. At the same time, I want to make clear that every single local area in England has work to do to make lives better for their children. This includes the 20 places where data show childhood is least hard.”
No simple correlations
There tends to be some correlation between deprivation and the findings in the report, but it also says: “These findings do not simply describe which areas are more and less deprived.”
Similarly, there is no simple north-south divide: “Local authorities with high and low scores are spread across England but scores are highest on average [good] in the south and lowest [bad] in the north, with the midlands in between. Looking regionally, it is local authorities in the south east of England which have the highest average scores. However, two of the six highest scoring local authorities are in the north (the two Cheshire unitary authorities), and eight of the 20 lowest scoring local authorities are in the south.”
The role of devolution
Dame Rachel makes 17 recommendations, including a state of emergency for children and a children’s emergency fund, and a deputy mayor for children in every strategic authority.
She sees an important role for devolution and regional mayors: “Giving power to local decision makers should lead to more responsive public services. This data shows that no two areas are the same,” she writes.
“Local policy makers and those delivering services must be able to react to the challenges their children face to improve their lives. For that to work, mayors and local decision makers must be given the right tools to improve children’s lives including access to centrally held data, funding to accompany new responsibilities and clearly defined minimum standards.”
More from the Mayor of Middlesbrough
Middlesbrough Mayor Chris Cooke added: ““This is a deeply personal issue for me. My own experiences in childhood are the reason why my main motivation as Mayor is to fight inequalities and push for opportunities for all children – in spite of whatever challenges they may face.
“It’s why I’m introducing the 10 by 10 scheme so that all children get 10 positive and potentially life-changing experiences before the age of 10. It will open doors for them and show them the fascinating career opportunities that are right here on their doorstep.
“We’re also opening more youth clubs – redressing the balance so that there’s one in every ward offering safe and free fun. And we’re pouring more money into school holiday clubs, helping schools with grants for new equipment and facilities and making sure families know how to access the welfare support they’re entitled to.
“All of these things take time to come to fruition, but we must invest in our young people’s futures to turn around generations of unfairness. It’s important to stress that councils can’t act alone – not at a time when upwards of 80% of our budget is spent on social care.
“It’s not just our police force that needs more funding – the wider system in our area is crying out for investment so that we can have good childhoods in every postcode. As the commissioner’s report says, only then will we have a chance of the growth in every postcode the country needs.
“That’s why I’ve written to Prime Minister Andy Burnham to make the case for Middlesbrough to get the extra help we need to ensure that no one is left behind. Middlesbrough’s children don’t deserve labels. They deserve the chance to thrive.”
*The Childhood Lottery: the hardest places to grow up in England.

What happens when the media itself becomes part of the problem? Who holds it to account? 14 years after the Leveson Inquiry reported its findings, has anything really changed? And how can we build something better?
Join Bylines Network on Wednesday 21 October, for a vital conversation about the media Britain needs — and what it will take to get there.
The event will conclude with a live audience Q&A.






