A bitterly cold 23 January morning on Redcar seafront. Just a few dog walkers about. Almost everyone else is at home, battening down the hatches in preparation for Storm Éowyn. But a handful of stragglers are on their way to Redcar Civic Centre. They’re not here to take in the bracing sea air, they’re on a mission. Two of them, Mick Johnstone and Tom Casey (no relation), are seasoned Stop Incineration North East (SINE) campaigners. The third one is me. We’re on the way to the civic centre to stop an incinerator...
Unexpected development
We hadn’t been expecting to do this. SINE was preparing for the next public meeting about the Grangetown incinerator aka the Tees Valley Energy Recovery Facility (TV ERF) to be held at the Eston and Normanby Social Club on Tuesday 28 January. Then on Friday 17 January we were notified by independent councillor Dr Tristan Learoyd that a planning application for a hazardous waste incinerator would be held at the Regulatory Committee of Redcar and Cleveland Borough Council (RCBC) the following Thursday. A word of explanation here. Some councils have straightforward planning committees. Others, such as RCBC, use a wider, regulatory, committee to deal with extras such as alcohol and taxi licencing.
If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck…
Commercial waste specialists CSG had applied for planning permission for the Wilton Waste Treatment Plant (WWTP), a euphemism for a hazardous waste incinerator. Tristan had got wind of the application, and called it in for consideration by the committee. The planning officers had intended to grant this application by means of a ‘delegated decision’, by which the approval is granted by a council officer rather than a committee of elected representatives. 90% of all planning decisions are made this way, but this wouldn’t usually apply to decisions of this magnitude. Unless the council was determined to allow planning permission regardless of any opposition. More on this later
A rush job
Over the weekend we hurriedly contacted the council’s planning administration team to see whether we could submit verbal or, failing this, written objections to the Regulatory Committee. There was some confusion over this, but it was soon confirmed that we could do both. However, the written versions needed to be submitted by 1pm on Monday, 20 January. So we worked furiously to prepare the documents, comparing notes so that we wouldn’t repeat what the others had said. The final versions of all three documents can be found in ‘further reading’ below.
Squeaky bum time
Are you nervous about public speaking? Don’t try to kid anyone, we all are. A shortened night’s sleep on the night before the meeting, then a few rehearsals to try to time the speech correctly. That’s easier than it sounds. You’ll overrun, everybody does. The meeting was due to start at 10am in the main chamber of the Civic Centre. It’s a modern and functional auditorium. I’d spent the previous year attending meetings of the Tees Valley Combined Authority (TVCA) at Teesside Airport, in rooms with poor acoustics, intermittent microphones, and the odd RAF fighter jet drowning out proceedings. So this was a step up.
The invisible woman
After about 30 minutes we were on to Agenda Item 7, Hazardous Waste to Energy Process Plant Wilton Waste Treatment Plant. The council officer led us to our seats and showed us how the microphones work. In the chair, Cllr Stuart Smith. But proceedings would be kept on a tight rein by the woman sitting immediately to Stuart’s right, Development Services Manager Claire Griffiths. Claire runs these meetings, but her name never appears in the agenda or minutes. She outlined the planning application, including a list of organisations who didn’t object to it. Everything was fine, nothing to see here, hand over to the chair and gavel it through in 20 minutes. Or so she thought. The chair called Tom Casey, the first of three members of the public to give verbal evidence to the committee
Come on down!
Tom gave an impassioned and eloquent summary focused on the attempt by the applicant and the planning officers to evade scrutiny by submitting the planning application on 23 December 2024, and disguising its function as an incinerator by referring to it as a ‘waste to energy plant’. The chair called time on Tom, but Tom defied him by appealing to anybody in the room to ask questions. There was silence. Mick Johnstone was up next, and highlighted the need to monitor emissions from facilities such as these. He’s had a lifetime experience of breaches of trust by companies who make promises about clean air, but then break them as soon as their plants become operational. Why not have community monitors, for example, to check and report pollution levels in real time?.
Tongue-tied and twisted
Then it was my turn. On these occasions, despite your preparations, you forget a lot of what you were going to say, and get through it as best you can. You are relieved when the chair calls time after three minutes, although I did remember to list the types of waste that CSG intends to burn at Wilton: paint sludge, resins/varnishes, detergents, pharmaceutical items, laboratory chemicals, pesticides, clinical waste and heavy fuel oil.
Seasoned veteran
Councillor Dr Tristan Learoyd was up next. Tristan is the former chair of this committee, and he knows how the system works. Tristan utterly destroyed the specious arguments of the joint Claire Griffiths/ESG team, busting them for using an outdated environmental assessment and failing to follow current legislation. Surely Claire Griffiths and ESG were aware of the new government policy on incinerators needing to be carbon capture ready? This policy was announced seven days after the company submitted their planning application, and just 24 days before this meeting, so it must have been fresh in their memories.
A company woman
Perhaps Jen Cartmell, director of waste treatment at CSG, could help us. CSG were an environmentally friendly company who did a lot of work with local schools etc etc. You know the drill. She skipped the bit about her company bragging that it had just climbed to 24th in the latest Sunday Times PwC ‘Profit Track’ listings, which rank the UK’s 100 private firms with the fastest growing profits. Jen’s incinerator would supply electricity to the national grid. How much? Two megawatts. Wait, no, 1.6 megawatts. Well, how about deducting the electricity needed to run the plant itself? Okay, make it one megawatt then. It was worth a go though.
We live in a democracy, right?
And so to the vote on this planning application. Lynn Pallister, councillor for Grangetown ward, and the area most likely to be negatively impacted by the incinerator, proposed a motion to oppose it on the grounds that her town was already surrounded by incinerators. Chair Stuart Smith and Claire Griffiths said that this wasn’t good enough. RCBC would need technical grounds to oppose the application. If they didn’t, they could be subject to a legal challenge from the applicant, which could eventually result in a substantial ‘costs’ award against the council. Claire, Cllr Smith, and RCBC Monitoring Officer Steven Newton have used this tactic before, to undemocratically overturn a previous committee decision to reject an application to build houses at Silverdale Gardens, in the last sliver of green belt between Redcar and Marske.
The unacceptable face of the planning process
But if you took Claire Griffiths’ arguments to their logical conclusion, there would be no point in opposing ANY planning applications because of fear of reprisals over costs. Cllr Pallister was forced to list the legislation under which she opposed the application. She duly did this, but then Claire began hectoring her about which specific parts of the legislation were applicable. But even the chair, Stuart Smith, had had enough of this, and he called a vote.
Numeracy problem
The hands went up, and Claire Griffiths counted them. Only four councillors were in favour. Not so fast Claire. There were several people in the chamber, including myself who had counted more than this, and we made our opinion known. Have another go. Oh, was Ian Hart holding his hand up? She hadn’t noticed him. Five votes then. Those against? Four. The motion was passed and the planning application was rejected. Loud applause from parts of the room. Not so much for the defeat of CSG and their incinerator, more for Claire Griffiths and her rediscovered ability to count beyond four.
One down, one to go
So we congratulated ourselves on a job well done. But attention will now turn to the next public meeting regarding the other Grangetown incinerator, also known as the TV ERF. It’s already made its way through RCBC’s planning process, but on the strength of recent developments, I have absolutely zero faith in that. Up until last Thursday I thought that the TV ERF would go ahead. But it’s on the skids right now, not least because of electricity supply problems, not to mention the same problems with carbon capture that hit the CSG hazardous waste incinerator. With the latest setback being a legal dispute over the bidding process, I’m more convinced than ever that not a single brick will be laid.
A hard rain’s a-gonna fall
As we left the meeting, Storm Éowyn, one of the most violent storms ever to hit the UK, was beginning to stir. The impending devastation about to be unleashed by yet another human-induced global warming event reminded us of why we showed up at Redcar Civic Centre on a freezing cold January morning.
Thanks to Councillor Dr Tristan Learoyd for technical assistance with this article
Further reading
Incinerator presentation by Tom Casey
Incinerator presentation by Mick Johnstone
Incinerator presentation by Ray Casey
RCBC Regulatory Committee agenda

CLICK HERE TO DONATE TO OUR CROWDFUNDER
HELP US BECOME STRONGER SO THAT WE CAN CONTINUE TO DELIVER POWERFUL CITIZEN JOURNALISM!






