• Contact
  • About
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
North East Bylines
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • European News
    • Health
    • Politics
    • Science
    • UK News
    • World News
    Cartoon of Liz Truss with shopping trolley

    Tory leadership election: policy shopping is no way to treat people

    Border control at Dover

    The moral argument for open borders

    the quilt

    Join Hands for Ukraine at the Royal Albert Hall

    Juárez, Chihuahua, Mexico, 08-06-2021 A man was shot to death in the streets of Juárez, the experts work at the crime scene.

    Mexico: new research shows the historic link between opening schools and falling murder rates

    Andy Preston, Middlesbrough Mayor

    Middlesbrough Mayor Andy Preston faces calls to resign over damning audit report

    The freight area at Teesside Airport

    The ostrich has landed: an update for visitors to Teesside Airport

    girl with violin in sunflower field

    Welcoming the Ukraine Freedom Orchestra: flags, a star and a gigantic quilt

    pills

    Active patients have better outcomes and may reduce the pressure on the NHS

    Keir Starmer

    You might as well cross the floor: an open letter to Keir Starmer

    Trending Tags

    • Ukraine
  • Culture
    • All
    • Animation
    • Books
    • Illustrations & More
    • Music
    • Performance
    • Poetry
    • Social Media
    • Theatre
    • TV & Radio
    street in Naples

    Five books to read that bring Naples to life

    Derry Girls mural

    Derry Girls: from the beginning

    Live Theatre sign

    Your Voice Your Future: North East

    white stag

    White Stag

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food & Drink
    • Health & Fitness
    Chef and son

    MasterChef’s’ Posh Street Food chef’s own summer of entertainment

    Scottish highlands

    The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

    Kleo Tabuku

    Top chef to open Newcastle restaurant, Lovage

    Pop up park

    Pop up to the park in Sunderland

    The Blackbird Inn, Ponteland

    The Blackbird Inn flies high with its new summer menu

    gymnast

    Culture of fear in British gymnastics uncovered by the Whyte Review

    Kennedy and Rhind

    Kennedy and Rhind: more time to enjoy a North East favourite

    Hoppings

    The Hoppings is back in Newcastle!

    Chi Onwurah MP

    Chi backs watchdog for fast fashion industry

    Trending Tags

    • Business
      • All
      • Economy
      • Rural
      • Technology
      • Trade
      • Voluntary Sector
      Scottish highlands

      The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

      loo

      A room with a loo

      Newcastle quayside

      Newcastle named as one of the best cities for graduates

      Brexit economics

      New research shows the economic effect of Brexit

      Wetherspoons pub

      Wetherspoons sparkle: has it gone flat?

      Leon Fussell rehearsing

      Unsung Heroes at Queen’s Hall, Hexham

      Houchen and spade

      Vampire daylight: a week in the life of Ben Houchen, Tees Valley Mayor

      Keir Starmer

      Open letter to Sir Keir Starmer

      London Bridge tube station

      A chance meeting with Mary: homeless and begging in a train station

      Trending Tags

      • Region
        • All
        • Co. Durham
        • North East
        • Northumberland
        • Teesside
        • Tyneside
        • Wearside
        Pride flag

        Northern Pride: Newcastle proves it’s loud, proud and still fighting

        Litterpick with Chi Onwurah

        Chi Onwurah publishes action plan for rubbish and calls on constituents to help improve it!

        the quilt

        Join Hands for Ukraine at the Royal Albert Hall

        Andy Preston, Middlesbrough Mayor

        Middlesbrough Mayor Andy Preston faces calls to resign over damning audit report

        The Wind in the Willows

        The Wind in the Willows and more at Queen’s Hall, Hexham

        The freight area at Teesside Airport

        The ostrich has landed: an update for visitors to Teesside Airport

        loo

        A room with a loo

        Kleo Tabuku

        Top chef to open Newcastle restaurant, Lovage

        mother and child with empty purse

        Welfare Rights support in Kenton, Newcastle

        Trending Tags

        • Opinion
          Titanic coming out of Southampton

          The 110th anniversary of the Titanic’s departure

          There is an England

          There is an England

          Prime Minister Boris Johnson signs the Withdrawal Agreement with the European Union"

          The parody of disinformation: Boris Johnson on Ukraine and Brexit

          Boris Johnson’s comments on Ukraine and Brexit are an insult

          TV Agency staff jumping in the air

          The TV Agency celebrates 10th anniversary with global success

          North East of County Dublin

          North East of England and North East of County Dublin: Compare and contrast

          North Sea oil rig

          Copping out of COP: Ukraine, fossil fuels and nuclear fusion

          Placard with Boris Johnson as a clown

          Dictators, media and mobility: erosion of identity, sustenance and safety

          close up on a child's eye

          Racism and misogyny where there should have been safeguarding and security

        No Result
        View All Result
        • Home
        • News
          • All
          • Brexit
          • Education
          • Environment
          • European News
          • Health
          • Politics
          • Science
          • UK News
          • World News
          Cartoon of Liz Truss with shopping trolley

          Tory leadership election: policy shopping is no way to treat people

          Border control at Dover

          The moral argument for open borders

          the quilt

          Join Hands for Ukraine at the Royal Albert Hall

          Juárez, Chihuahua, Mexico, 08-06-2021 A man was shot to death in the streets of Juárez, the experts work at the crime scene.

          Mexico: new research shows the historic link between opening schools and falling murder rates

          Andy Preston, Middlesbrough Mayor

          Middlesbrough Mayor Andy Preston faces calls to resign over damning audit report

          The freight area at Teesside Airport

          The ostrich has landed: an update for visitors to Teesside Airport

          girl with violin in sunflower field

          Welcoming the Ukraine Freedom Orchestra: flags, a star and a gigantic quilt

          pills

          Active patients have better outcomes and may reduce the pressure on the NHS

          Keir Starmer

          You might as well cross the floor: an open letter to Keir Starmer

          Trending Tags

          • Ukraine
        • Culture
          • All
          • Animation
          • Books
          • Illustrations & More
          • Music
          • Performance
          • Poetry
          • Social Media
          • Theatre
          • TV & Radio
          street in Naples

          Five books to read that bring Naples to life

          Derry Girls mural

          Derry Girls: from the beginning

          Live Theatre sign

          Your Voice Your Future: North East

          white stag

          White Stag

        • Lifestyle
          • All
          • Fashion
          • Food & Drink
          • Health & Fitness
          Chef and son

          MasterChef’s’ Posh Street Food chef’s own summer of entertainment

          Scottish highlands

          The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

          Kleo Tabuku

          Top chef to open Newcastle restaurant, Lovage

          Pop up park

          Pop up to the park in Sunderland

          The Blackbird Inn, Ponteland

          The Blackbird Inn flies high with its new summer menu

          gymnast

          Culture of fear in British gymnastics uncovered by the Whyte Review

          Kennedy and Rhind

          Kennedy and Rhind: more time to enjoy a North East favourite

          Hoppings

          The Hoppings is back in Newcastle!

          Chi Onwurah MP

          Chi backs watchdog for fast fashion industry

          Trending Tags

          • Business
            • All
            • Economy
            • Rural
            • Technology
            • Trade
            • Voluntary Sector
            Scottish highlands

            The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

            loo

            A room with a loo

            Newcastle quayside

            Newcastle named as one of the best cities for graduates

            Brexit economics

            New research shows the economic effect of Brexit

            Wetherspoons pub

            Wetherspoons sparkle: has it gone flat?

            Leon Fussell rehearsing

            Unsung Heroes at Queen’s Hall, Hexham

            Houchen and spade

            Vampire daylight: a week in the life of Ben Houchen, Tees Valley Mayor

            Keir Starmer

            Open letter to Sir Keir Starmer

            London Bridge tube station

            A chance meeting with Mary: homeless and begging in a train station

            Trending Tags

            • Region
              • All
              • Co. Durham
              • North East
              • Northumberland
              • Teesside
              • Tyneside
              • Wearside
              Pride flag

              Northern Pride: Newcastle proves it’s loud, proud and still fighting

              Litterpick with Chi Onwurah

              Chi Onwurah publishes action plan for rubbish and calls on constituents to help improve it!

              the quilt

              Join Hands for Ukraine at the Royal Albert Hall

              Andy Preston, Middlesbrough Mayor

              Middlesbrough Mayor Andy Preston faces calls to resign over damning audit report

              The Wind in the Willows

              The Wind in the Willows and more at Queen’s Hall, Hexham

              The freight area at Teesside Airport

              The ostrich has landed: an update for visitors to Teesside Airport

              loo

              A room with a loo

              Kleo Tabuku

              Top chef to open Newcastle restaurant, Lovage

              mother and child with empty purse

              Welfare Rights support in Kenton, Newcastle

              Trending Tags

              • Opinion
                Titanic coming out of Southampton

                The 110th anniversary of the Titanic’s departure

                There is an England

                There is an England

                Prime Minister Boris Johnson signs the Withdrawal Agreement with the European Union"

                The parody of disinformation: Boris Johnson on Ukraine and Brexit

                Boris Johnson’s comments on Ukraine and Brexit are an insult

                TV Agency staff jumping in the air

                The TV Agency celebrates 10th anniversary with global success

                North East of County Dublin

                North East of England and North East of County Dublin: Compare and contrast

                North Sea oil rig

                Copping out of COP: Ukraine, fossil fuels and nuclear fusion

                Placard with Boris Johnson as a clown

                Dictators, media and mobility: erosion of identity, sustenance and safety

                close up on a child's eye

                Racism and misogyny where there should have been safeguarding and security

              No Result
              View All Result
              North East Bylines
              No Result
              View All Result
              Home News European News

              The moral argument for open borders

              Closed borders do not give us sovereignty but rather they diminish our freedom.

              David RosebyDavid Rose
              03-08-2022 12:21
              in European News, Politics
              Border control at Dover

              Photo by Alicia G. Monedero from shutterstock

              Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
              ADVERTISEMENT

              Queues at Dover have us all  thinking about borders again. On a more mundane level, I recently walked with a family and a dog through the land border between Germany (EU) and Switzerland (non-EU) under Basel train station without a single control in sight. The current need to stamp passports was not an inevitable result of Brexit, but a political choice. It could have been as simple as driving on the A1 at Berwick, going from England to Scotland. At least, as it is now.

              Why was the choice made to raise a border?

              The last time I thought seriously about borders was when I serendipitously chose to go to a political thought conference and I found myself in the bar with two of the contributors to a session on borders. I wondered whether there was an ontology of borders: positivist (those drawn on a map), realist (explained by natural, geographical features), and irrealist (constructed by the human mind); obviously assuming the latter was the most obvious explanation. Then, before Brexit, it was merely a theoretical game.

              No more. Now it matters.

              It is a platitude to say that borders are to keep people in rather than out, even if the media and political discourse are obsessed with the opposite. However, it strikes me that a border is to be understood in two ways to make sense of this platitude: the basis for national identity and, less expressed, the need for a “natural” limit on the mobility of (certain) people.

              Nationalism and identity

              Borders contain people in two ways: physically and in the mind. A people is not a race, nor an ethnicity, nor even a language. A people is an accidental group which inhabits a territory under political control. That accidental identity can be either positive or negative. Positively it can be the Scottish model (or Irish and Ukrainian, but that would be to make a claim for countries I feel less sure to speak for) where a land becomes the tradition that was lost and is now regained. But such an understanding requires an open border, to visit others and know one’s differences and to let others visit you and celebrate your difference. To let people flow in and out of your territory. Only then do you know who you truly are.

              Negatively it is the nationalism of England (perhaps of Russia or North Korea): exclusion and isolation. Negatively, not only can you say you cannot cross the border to work, but you cast a narrative that those on the other side of the border do not want you, are jealous of you, want to be you, fear you. The reality outside the border never corresponds, though, because you think you already know who you are. Currently, in Europe, I can testify there is no dislike, but merely a range of responses about Brexit from indifference to befuddlement of the decision England took. A physical barrier is never enough to keep a people in. The mind itself must also choose to keep itself oppressed and that is why we are told of the “revenge” of the French, the “spite” of EU, when, in reality, they act as states mostly do: rational agents pursuing interests.

              Containment

              But why construct both barriers and myths to keep the people in? Let us speculate on the near future if the economic and political status quo remains: the UK will be less productive, more heavily privatised, wages will not rise, benefits will be cut, competition between individuals will keep wages low, all these just to keep profits of companies high. We now have the “cost of living crisis” but read for that “austerity” or “market logic” and realise this is another political choice. To keep profits high. This is the vaunted Singapore economy, one of disparity and inequality. This is the idea of charter cities or free ports where a corporation controls a small territory and an immobile workforce, since health, security and rights are localised to the corporate level.

              The rabble

              Such a world constructs what Hegel called the “rabble”: a class whose freedom is diminished because economic conditions of existence make individual, free choice impossible. One is tied to one’s needs and to those who satisfy those needs. In such a world, Hegel wants the rabble removed to avoid political instability, but in our world, legislation against collective action and protest guarantee stability. In such a world, members of this class would seek a better life elsewhere.

              That is what migrants are. People who move from Newcastle to Birmingham, London or Edinburgh for a better job or education are migrants. They do so — as individuals or families — as we all would, to have something better when it is no longer possible at home. That some move across artificially created borders is about control. You can work in Birmingham if you are from Newcastle but not from Sofia. Soon, charter cities may well create smaller borders; you will be able to work only in the North East because only there are you entitled to health, housing, work. Corporate and privatised charter cities.

              And that is why it becomes a moral obligation to have open borders.

              To understand ourselves but, more importantly, closed borders do not give us, as they so vociferously argued, the illusory freedom of sovereignty, that ambivalent and empty word. Closed borders diminish our personal freedom and reduce our autonomy to mere rabble for the rich corporations.


              We need your help! The press in our country is dominated by billionaire-owned media, many offshore and avoiding paying tax. We are a citizen journalism publication but still have significant costs. If you believe in what we do, please consider subscribing to the Bylines Gazette 🙏

              ADVERTISEMENT
              Previous Post

              MasterChef’s’ Posh Street Food chef’s own summer of entertainment

              Next Post

              The Causeway: new high-energy, family-friendly show celebrating North East heritage

              David Rose

              David Rose

              David Rose writes and lectures in philosophy and although he has moved about a bit has been settled as a southerner in what he calls ‘the northern wastes’ of Newcastle upon Tyne, England for some time with his wife and half-Italian kids. He has published widely in philosophy, some youthful flirtations with poetry (but came to realize that the medium has ‘long been superseded by pop music’), and has published a few horror stories here and there, largely urban gothic mash-ups of M R James and Lars Von Trier.

              Related Posts

              Cartoon of Liz Truss with shopping trolley
              Opinion

              Tory leadership election: policy shopping is no way to treat people

              byPeter Benson
              August 4, 2022
              the quilt
              Culture

              Join Hands for Ukraine at the Royal Albert Hall

              byYvonne Wanckeand1 others
              August 1, 2022
              Andy Preston, Middlesbrough Mayor
              Politics

              Middlesbrough Mayor Andy Preston faces calls to resign over damning audit report

              byJulia Mazza
              August 1, 2022
              The freight area at Teesside Airport
              Politics

              The ostrich has landed: an update for visitors to Teesside Airport

              byScott Hunter
              July 31, 2022
              girl with violin in sunflower field
              European News

              Welcoming the Ukraine Freedom Orchestra: flags, a star and a gigantic quilt

              byDaisy Windsorand1 others
              July 30, 2022
              Next Post
              The Causeway

              The Causeway: new high-energy, family-friendly show celebrating North East heritage

              Want to support us?

              Can you help North East Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

              DONATE

              Sign up to our newsletter

              If you would like to receive the North East Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

              NEWSLETTER

              LATEST

              street in Naples

              Five books to read that bring Naples to life

              August 7, 2022
              Derry Girls mural

              Derry Girls: from the beginning

              August 6, 2022
              Live Theatre sign

              Your Voice Your Future: North East

              August 6, 2022
              white stag

              White Stag

              August 5, 2022
              Sunak foot in mouth cartoon

              Taking from the poor to pay the rich

              August 5, 2022
              Pride flag

              Northern Pride: Newcastle proves it’s loud, proud and still fighting

              August 5, 2022

              MOST READ

              street in Naples

              Five books to read that bring Naples to life

              August 7, 2022
              Derry Girls mural

              Derry Girls: from the beginning

              August 6, 2022
              Live Theatre sign

              Your Voice Your Future: North East

              August 6, 2022
              white stag

              White Stag

              August 5, 2022

              BROWSE BY TAGS

              Audio Beach Brexit Business castle leazes climate activism Co. Durham cost of living crisis Culture defra democracy ducklings Economy Education Environment fire and rescue firefighter Food & Drink food poverty Health Health & Care Home Affairs just stop oil Lifestyle Local Lockdown Northumberland Peace Performance Politics pride month refugee rescue Science Social Media Teesside TV & Radio Tynemouth Tyneside Ukraine volunteer Wearside

              We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in the North East and beyond.

              North East Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Network Limited, which is a sister organisation to Byline Times. The Bylines Network and Byline Times are financially, legally and editorially separate entities.

              Learn more about us

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Contact
              • About
              • Letters
              • Donate
              • Privacy
              • Bylines network
              • Shop

              © 2022 North East Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Home
              • News
                • Brexit
                • Education
                • Environment
                • UK News
                • Transport
                • World News
              • Politics
              • Opinion
              • Lifestyle
                • Culture
                • Music
                • Poetry
              • Business
                • Economy
                • Technology
                • Trade
              • Donate
              • Newsletter sign up
              • Boriiis Cartoons
              • Authors

              © 2022 North East Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              Welcome Back!

              Login to your account below

              Forgotten Password?

              Retrieve your password

              Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

              Log In