• Contact
  • About
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
North East Bylines
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • European News
    • Health
    • Politics
    • Science
    • UK News
    • World News
    Cartoon of Liz Truss with shopping trolley

    Tory leadership election: policy shopping is no way to treat people

    Border control at Dover

    The moral argument for open borders

    the quilt

    Join Hands for Ukraine at the Royal Albert Hall

    Juárez, Chihuahua, Mexico, 08-06-2021 A man was shot to death in the streets of Juárez, the experts work at the crime scene.

    Mexico: new research shows the historic link between opening schools and falling murder rates

    Andy Preston, Middlesbrough Mayor

    Middlesbrough Mayor Andy Preston faces calls to resign over damning audit report

    The freight area at Teesside Airport

    The ostrich has landed: an update for visitors to Teesside Airport

    girl with violin in sunflower field

    Welcoming the Ukraine Freedom Orchestra: flags, a star and a gigantic quilt

    pills

    Active patients have better outcomes and may reduce the pressure on the NHS

    Keir Starmer

    You might as well cross the floor: an open letter to Keir Starmer

    Trending Tags

    • Ukraine
  • Culture
    • All
    • Animation
    • Books
    • Illustrations & More
    • Music
    • Performance
    • Poetry
    • Social Media
    • Theatre
    • TV & Radio
    street in Naples

    Five books to read that bring Naples to life

    Derry Girls mural

    Derry Girls: from the beginning

    Live Theatre sign

    Your Voice Your Future: North East

    white stag

    White Stag

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food & Drink
    • Health & Fitness
    Prezzo

    Discovering the new summer menu at Prezzo

    Chef and son

    MasterChef’s’ Posh Street Food chef’s own summer of entertainment

    Scottish highlands

    The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

    Kleo Tabuku

    Top chef to open Newcastle restaurant, Lovage

    Pop up park

    Pop up to the park in Sunderland

    The Blackbird Inn, Ponteland

    The Blackbird Inn flies high with its new summer menu

    gymnast

    Culture of fear in British gymnastics uncovered by the Whyte Review

    Kennedy and Rhind

    Kennedy and Rhind: more time to enjoy a North East favourite

    Hoppings

    The Hoppings is back in Newcastle!

    Trending Tags

    • Business
      • All
      • Economy
      • Rural
      • Technology
      • Trade
      • Voluntary Sector
      Scottish highlands

      The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

      loo

      A room with a loo

      Newcastle quayside

      Newcastle named as one of the best cities for graduates

      Brexit economics

      New research shows the economic effect of Brexit

      Wetherspoons pub

      Wetherspoons sparkle: has it gone flat?

      Leon Fussell rehearsing

      Unsung Heroes at Queen’s Hall, Hexham

      Houchen and spade

      Vampire daylight: a week in the life of Ben Houchen, Tees Valley Mayor

      Keir Starmer

      Open letter to Sir Keir Starmer

      London Bridge tube station

      A chance meeting with Mary: homeless and begging in a train station

      Trending Tags

      • Region
        • All
        • Co. Durham
        • North East
        • Northumberland
        • Teesside
        • Tyneside
        • Wearside
        Pride flag

        Northern Pride: Newcastle proves it’s loud, proud and still fighting

        Litterpick with Chi Onwurah

        Chi Onwurah publishes action plan for rubbish and calls on constituents to help improve it!

        the quilt

        Join Hands for Ukraine at the Royal Albert Hall

        Andy Preston, Middlesbrough Mayor

        Middlesbrough Mayor Andy Preston faces calls to resign over damning audit report

        The Wind in the Willows

        The Wind in the Willows and more at Queen’s Hall, Hexham

        The freight area at Teesside Airport

        The ostrich has landed: an update for visitors to Teesside Airport

        loo

        A room with a loo

        Kleo Tabuku

        Top chef to open Newcastle restaurant, Lovage

        mother and child with empty purse

        Welfare Rights support in Kenton, Newcastle

        Trending Tags

        • Opinion
          Titanic coming out of Southampton

          The 110th anniversary of the Titanic’s departure

          There is an England

          There is an England

          Prime Minister Boris Johnson signs the Withdrawal Agreement with the European Union"

          The parody of disinformation: Boris Johnson on Ukraine and Brexit

          Boris Johnson’s comments on Ukraine and Brexit are an insult

          TV Agency staff jumping in the air

          The TV Agency celebrates 10th anniversary with global success

          North East of County Dublin

          North East of England and North East of County Dublin: Compare and contrast

          North Sea oil rig

          Copping out of COP: Ukraine, fossil fuels and nuclear fusion

          Placard with Boris Johnson as a clown

          Dictators, media and mobility: erosion of identity, sustenance and safety

          close up on a child's eye

          Racism and misogyny where there should have been safeguarding and security

        No Result
        View All Result
        • Home
        • News
          • All
          • Brexit
          • Education
          • Environment
          • European News
          • Health
          • Politics
          • Science
          • UK News
          • World News
          Cartoon of Liz Truss with shopping trolley

          Tory leadership election: policy shopping is no way to treat people

          Border control at Dover

          The moral argument for open borders

          the quilt

          Join Hands for Ukraine at the Royal Albert Hall

          Juárez, Chihuahua, Mexico, 08-06-2021 A man was shot to death in the streets of Juárez, the experts work at the crime scene.

          Mexico: new research shows the historic link between opening schools and falling murder rates

          Andy Preston, Middlesbrough Mayor

          Middlesbrough Mayor Andy Preston faces calls to resign over damning audit report

          The freight area at Teesside Airport

          The ostrich has landed: an update for visitors to Teesside Airport

          girl with violin in sunflower field

          Welcoming the Ukraine Freedom Orchestra: flags, a star and a gigantic quilt

          pills

          Active patients have better outcomes and may reduce the pressure on the NHS

          Keir Starmer

          You might as well cross the floor: an open letter to Keir Starmer

          Trending Tags

          • Ukraine
        • Culture
          • All
          • Animation
          • Books
          • Illustrations & More
          • Music
          • Performance
          • Poetry
          • Social Media
          • Theatre
          • TV & Radio
          street in Naples

          Five books to read that bring Naples to life

          Derry Girls mural

          Derry Girls: from the beginning

          Live Theatre sign

          Your Voice Your Future: North East

          white stag

          White Stag

        • Lifestyle
          • All
          • Fashion
          • Food & Drink
          • Health & Fitness
          Prezzo

          Discovering the new summer menu at Prezzo

          Chef and son

          MasterChef’s’ Posh Street Food chef’s own summer of entertainment

          Scottish highlands

          The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

          Kleo Tabuku

          Top chef to open Newcastle restaurant, Lovage

          Pop up park

          Pop up to the park in Sunderland

          The Blackbird Inn, Ponteland

          The Blackbird Inn flies high with its new summer menu

          gymnast

          Culture of fear in British gymnastics uncovered by the Whyte Review

          Kennedy and Rhind

          Kennedy and Rhind: more time to enjoy a North East favourite

          Hoppings

          The Hoppings is back in Newcastle!

          Trending Tags

          • Business
            • All
            • Economy
            • Rural
            • Technology
            • Trade
            • Voluntary Sector
            Scottish highlands

            The beauty of the Scottish Highlands

            loo

            A room with a loo

            Newcastle quayside

            Newcastle named as one of the best cities for graduates

            Brexit economics

            New research shows the economic effect of Brexit

            Wetherspoons pub

            Wetherspoons sparkle: has it gone flat?

            Leon Fussell rehearsing

            Unsung Heroes at Queen’s Hall, Hexham

            Houchen and spade

            Vampire daylight: a week in the life of Ben Houchen, Tees Valley Mayor

            Keir Starmer

            Open letter to Sir Keir Starmer

            London Bridge tube station

            A chance meeting with Mary: homeless and begging in a train station

            Trending Tags

            • Region
              • All
              • Co. Durham
              • North East
              • Northumberland
              • Teesside
              • Tyneside
              • Wearside
              Pride flag

              Northern Pride: Newcastle proves it’s loud, proud and still fighting

              Litterpick with Chi Onwurah

              Chi Onwurah publishes action plan for rubbish and calls on constituents to help improve it!

              the quilt

              Join Hands for Ukraine at the Royal Albert Hall

              Andy Preston, Middlesbrough Mayor

              Middlesbrough Mayor Andy Preston faces calls to resign over damning audit report

              The Wind in the Willows

              The Wind in the Willows and more at Queen’s Hall, Hexham

              The freight area at Teesside Airport

              The ostrich has landed: an update for visitors to Teesside Airport

              loo

              A room with a loo

              Kleo Tabuku

              Top chef to open Newcastle restaurant, Lovage

              mother and child with empty purse

              Welfare Rights support in Kenton, Newcastle

              Trending Tags

              • Opinion
                Titanic coming out of Southampton

                The 110th anniversary of the Titanic’s departure

                There is an England

                There is an England

                Prime Minister Boris Johnson signs the Withdrawal Agreement with the European Union"

                The parody of disinformation: Boris Johnson on Ukraine and Brexit

                Boris Johnson’s comments on Ukraine and Brexit are an insult

                TV Agency staff jumping in the air

                The TV Agency celebrates 10th anniversary with global success

                North East of County Dublin

                North East of England and North East of County Dublin: Compare and contrast

                North Sea oil rig

                Copping out of COP: Ukraine, fossil fuels and nuclear fusion

                Placard with Boris Johnson as a clown

                Dictators, media and mobility: erosion of identity, sustenance and safety

                close up on a child's eye

                Racism and misogyny where there should have been safeguarding and security

              No Result
              View All Result
              North East Bylines
              No Result
              View All Result
              Home News Politics

              The Online Safety Bill: threats to free speech

              There are roughly three approaches to free speech...

              Dylan NeribyDylan Neri
              20-06-2021 07:00
              in Politics, UK, UK News, World News
              person with sticky tape over mouth

              Photo by Bermix Studio from unsplash

              Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
              ADVERTISEMENT

              Freedom of speech is perhaps the most ancient right in human history. Since Eve did first eat from the ‘tree of knowledge’ humankind has known the temptation of thinking for itself, for investigating what is forbidden or considered beyond our capacities of thought and reason. When Milton refers to the ‘known laws of ancient liberty,’ he alludes to those rights innate in thinking creatures, that have been degraded by authority for the purposes of power since Man did first establish government. For the fundamental argument is one of authority versus criticism: the ultimate authority is either God or Nature; and the right of one person to establish control over the thoughts and opinions of another must be established in advance. And this forms the basis for every free speech argument in history.   

              Limits on free speech to protect minorities?

              In the modern world of liberal democracy, the argument has undergone various revisions and appears to us in a new form. Rather than the traditional argument of restricting speech to preserve power and order, the concern now is for the protection of minorities. The fundamental roles have been inverted. Where once the tyrant arrested the dissident for questioning his authority, now the dissident assumes the role of tyrant in a world where all minorities must be protected. In this line of argument, forms of speech that should be restricted include (i) hate speech; (ii) speech that incites violence; and, (iii) offensive speech.  

              The age of social media has further complicated the argument. The democratisation of information heralded by the founders of the internet contained a sinister sub-clause: the democratisation of opinion and fact, and an unrestrained right to communicate with a significant portion of the world. In the context of the three arguments for modern speech restrictions: the internet and social media enable the spread of hate speech and offensive language and the incitement of violence to such an extent, and with such ease, that censoring is not so much unavoidable but rather required.  

              Who should censor free speech?

              But there’s the rub. Who exactly is to be our censor – to whom do we award that right? Thomas Paine wrote that “Government, even in its best state, is but a necessary evil; in its worst state, an intolerable one.” And the question of necessity is essential. Is it necessary for the state to limit the free expression of its citizens, in any medium? Or do we allow private organisations to regulate their own sites, in accordance with real-world laws, and allow the individual to exercise his own free will? In the liberal attempt to create a societal Utopia free from offence and hate, a blissful Disneyland of the mind, two forms of legislation have been introduced. The German Network Enforcement Law (Netzwerkdurchsetzungsgesetz – NetzDG) and the Online Harms White Paper in the UK.  

              According to Justitia, the former “is perhaps the most widely debated and controversial initiative enacted by a liberal democracy to counter illegal online content.” It was adopted after unsuccessful attempts by the German government to persuade Facebook to enforce its own community standards rigorously, and remove hate speech which violates German law. The law imposes intermediary liability for social media networks with over two million registered users, and requires these platforms to remove illegal content (as defined in 22 provisions of the German criminal code), including hate speech and “defamation of religions”, and provides a vast censorious blanket to cover everything from insult of public office to actual threats of violence.  

              Upon its passing, Human Rights Watch declared that the law “can lead to unaccountable, overbroad censorship and should be promptly reversed.” Wenzel Michalski, Germany director at Human Rights Watch, said the new German law is “fundamentally flawed… it is vague, overbroad, and turns private companies into overzealous censors to avoid steep fines, leaving users with no judicial oversight or right to appeal.” They also warned that it would set a dangerous precedent for other governments looking to restrict speech online by forcing companies to censor on the government’s behalf.  

              The Online Safety Bill

              But this warning did not stop the publishing of the Online Harms White Paper in the UK, which will be introduced as the Online Safety Bill this year. The moral foundations of the legislation are virtually identical to those of the NetzDG – limit the spread of offensive language and hate, to make the internet a nicer place to be – but the scope of the content regulated leaves the NetzDG looking rather modest. The White Paper covers a range of harms that cover illegal conduct, such as distributing terrorist content and harassment, as well as legal conduct that is considered harmful, for instance disinformation, trolling and intimidation, and, strangely, excessive screen time. By contrast, content is only designated illegal under the NetzDG if it falls under one of the provisions of the German criminal code. With the NetzDG we see more of an attempt to align the virtual society with its real-world parallel, while the White Paper appears to consider certain legal offences illegal, or at least morally reprehensible, when carried out online, so as to require a unique code of conduct. 

              Approaches to free speech

              This disconnection is not a surprise. There are roughly three approaches to free speech: the absolutist approach of the United States, outlined in the First Amendment to the Constitution; the authoritarian approach, that says speech must be limited to ensure order and stability, for the safety of the collective; and, a third approach, encapsulated by the blurry wording of the European Convention on Human Rights, Article 10, with its dubious reference to the “duties and responsibilities”, which argues that free expression must occasionally be restricted to the benefit of the minority. The only difference between the latter two is the designation of the censor: in one it is the morally enlightened government, or Ofcom, in the other it is the Dear Leader. But in each case, the power of thinking for oneself is surrendered to a higher authority; and never does this lead to a positive outcome.  

              And so the prophecy of the dangerous precedent is fulfilled. Less than two years after the NetzDG law went into effect, several states have been inspired by the noble cause of eliminating hate and offence. Last year Turkey passed a new bill to severely limit online freedoms, the result of tweets which the apparently progressive and enlightened President Erdogan found offensive. The new bill will eliminate hate speech and harassment online – just like the Online Safety Bill, but with a different censor – by requiring social media platforms with more than one-million users to appoint a local representative in Turkey. And if there were any doubts about the sincerity of the progressive idealism of this bill, which will enable unprecedented control of speech online in the country, Turkish lawmakers explicitly referred to the German law and a similar initiative in France as a positive example. And the success of the liberal ideal does not stop there. A recent study reports that at least thirteen countries including Russia (progressive?) and India (blasphemy laws!) have proposed or enacted laws based on the regulatory structure of NetzDG.  

              It might seem as though the argument has become sufficiently complex as to require new genius to present a clear path to reason. Does our modern sense of morality require that speech be restricted to protect minority groups? And in the context of a universal social media one might despair. But the apparent complexity is no more than a Gordian knot, efficiently and cleanly sliced by the classical free speech arguments. For the fundamental question to be answered, whether relating to totalitarian governments or infallible Popes or the protection of persecuted peoples, is this: Who decides what is and is not acceptable?   

              By the very nature of the argument, almost all speech restrictions have been established from Divine Authority, whether religious or political. To take just three examples: Socrates, Jesus Christ and Galileo; each charged with blasphemy, or, more precisely, for denying the orthodox views of the majority – what was claimed to be known in advance. In the case of Socrates there was the further charge of corrupting the youth of Athens by making the weaker argument the stronger, neatly demonstrating the emancipating power inherent in the dialectical. Three men who influenced Western thought more than any other in history; each condemned for the simple act of questioning the views of the majority. Their arguments no doubt caused offence, yet the charge of ‘inciting’ violence is never used in the context of their teachings.  

              The death of Socrates. He challenged the accepted authority at the time and was charged with blasphemy. Free speech was not allowed.
              The death of Socrates

              In the legislation introduced by the U.K. and Germany, and in the case of the latter copied mutatis mutandis by autocratic regimes for the purpose of censorship, we see a continuation of the argument from Divine Authority. Now the censors know in advance what will be considered offensive, or hateful, or lead to violence, and in name of our Holy Liberal Ideals decide for us what we can and cannot say, or read, or write. Ofcom and the German government have as much right to this control as do President Erdogan and Vladimir Putin. For who decides that their definition of what is offensive or hateful is better or worse than those enlightened democracies of the West? 

              The atomised units of censorship arising in the world, with each having its own interpretation of the Progressive Ideals, each striving for a Utopian world beyond this one, reminds one of the situation in the infant United States, whereby religious denominations fought for supremacy within the new republic. The logical solution presented by Thomas Jefferson was to say that, “our civil rights have no dependence on religious opinions, more than our opinions in physics or geometry.” To guarantee true freedom, the state shall favour no religion at all. This ensured a free and open society, and was the basis of the First Amendment to the Constitution – the extension of this to the world of social media follows logically, and seems to be the only guarantee of true freedom of thought in any society.  

              John Stuart Mill understood this problem of human nature, when he wrote that, “the disposition of mankind, whether as rulers or as fellow citizens, to impose their opinions and inclinations as a rule of conduct on others is so energetically supported by some of the best and some of the worst feelings incident to human nature that it is hardly ever kept under restraint by anything but want of power.”  The path most conducive to free and open society is the one which least allows for such inclinations to become relevant. Accepting this, the essential separation becomes more necessary, not less, when taken in the context of universal social media. And the continuing trend of social media toward increasingly atomised units of opinion means that more discussion is necessary, not less. For if liberty means anything at all it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear. 

              ADVERTISEMENT
              Previous Post

              Tyne Bridge: celebrating 100 years

              Next Post

              Covid and me: some highs and lows

              Dylan Neri

              Dylan Neri

              Related Posts

              Cartoon of Liz Truss with shopping trolley
              Opinion

              Tory leadership election: policy shopping is no way to treat people

              byPeter Benson
              August 4, 2022
              Border control at Dover
              European News

              The moral argument for open borders

              byDavid Rose
              August 3, 2022
              the quilt
              Culture

              Join Hands for Ukraine at the Royal Albert Hall

              byYvonne Wanckeand1 others
              August 1, 2022
              Juárez, Chihuahua, Mexico, 08-06-2021 A man was shot to death in the streets of Juárez, the experts work at the crime scene.
              Education

              Mexico: new research shows the historic link between opening schools and falling murder rates

              byRaul Zepeda Gil
              August 1, 2022
              Andy Preston, Middlesbrough Mayor
              Politics

              Middlesbrough Mayor Andy Preston faces calls to resign over damning audit report

              byJulia Mazza
              August 1, 2022
              Next Post
              stage door

              Covid and me: some highs and lows

              Want to support us?

              Can you help North East Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

              DONATE

              Sign up to our newsletter

              If you would like to receive the North East Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

              NEWSLETTER

              LATEST

              Prezzo

              Discovering the new summer menu at Prezzo

              August 8, 2022
              street in Naples

              Five books to read that bring Naples to life

              August 7, 2022
              Derry Girls mural

              Derry Girls: from the beginning

              August 6, 2022
              Live Theatre sign

              Your Voice Your Future: North East

              August 6, 2022
              white stag

              White Stag

              August 5, 2022
              Sunak foot in mouth cartoon

              Taking from the poor to pay the rich

              August 5, 2022

              MOST READ

              Prezzo

              Discovering the new summer menu at Prezzo

              August 8, 2022
              street in Naples

              Five books to read that bring Naples to life

              August 7, 2022
              Derry Girls mural

              Derry Girls: from the beginning

              August 6, 2022
              Live Theatre sign

              Your Voice Your Future: North East

              August 6, 2022

              BROWSE BY TAGS

              Audio Beach Brexit Business castle leazes climate activism Co. Durham cost of living crisis Culture defra democracy ducklings Economy Education Environment fire and rescue firefighter Food & Drink food poverty Health Health & Care Home Affairs just stop oil Lifestyle Local Lockdown Northumberland Peace Performance Politics pride month refugee rescue Science Social Media Teesside TV & Radio Tynemouth Tyneside Ukraine volunteer Wearside

              We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in the North East and beyond.

              North East Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Network Limited, which is a sister organisation to Byline Times. The Bylines Network and Byline Times are financially, legally and editorially separate entities.

              Learn more about us

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Contact
              • About
              • Letters
              • Donate
              • Privacy
              • Bylines network
              • Shop

              © 2022 North East Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Home
              • News
                • Brexit
                • Education
                • Environment
                • UK News
                • Transport
                • World News
              • Politics
              • Opinion
              • Lifestyle
                • Culture
                • Music
                • Poetry
              • Business
                • Economy
                • Technology
                • Trade
              • Donate
              • Newsletter sign up
              • Boriiis Cartoons
              • Authors

              © 2022 North East Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              Welcome Back!

              Login to your account below

              Forgotten Password?

              Retrieve your password

              Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

              Log In